Environmental and biotic filters interact to shape the coexistence of native and introduced bees in northern Patagonian forests

• Published in: Agriculture, ecosystems & environment ecosystems & environment, 2023-06, Vol.349, p.108465, Article 108465
• Main Authors: Vergara, Pablo M., Fierro, Andrés, Carvajal, Mario A., Alaniz, Alberto J., Zorondo-Rodríguez, Francisco, Cifuentes, María C., Castro, Sergio A.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Bee abundance; Giant bumblebees; Remote-sensing variables; Species co-occurrence; Species dominance
• ISSN: 0167-8809; 1873-2305
• DOI: 10.1016/j.agee.2023.108465

Native and introduced species can coexist in rich ecosystems where competition for resources is less intense; however, native species can be excluded from suitable habitats hosting a high abundance of introduced species. To test these hypotheses, we estimated the probability of introduced bees (buff-tailed bumblebees and honeybees) to co-occur and dominate giant bumblebees in forested landscapes of northern Patagonia. We evaluated the effects of 29 remote-sensing variables of forest ecosystems on bee abundance using data from 56 landscapes. Then, we used a probabilistic Bayesian model to estimate the effects of the most important predictors of bee abundance on their co-occurrence and dominance probabilities. Introduced and native bees exhibited heterogeneous and scale-dependent responses to environmental conditions, with only six variables affecting their co-occurrence and dominance probabilities. A high maximum temperature was associated with both a decreased co-occurrence and an increased dominance of introduced bumblebees, and the opposed pattern was found for vegetation continuous fields, an index of canopy continuity. Similar responses were found for the co-occurrence probability of honeybees and giant bumblebees. Thus, species dominance and co-occurrence changed differently along environmental gradients, with co-occurrence increasing as native and introduced species become more abundant. A high dominance of introduced bees in unsuitable habitats suggests interspecific competition is strengthened as resources become scarcer, thus reinforcing the idea that abiotic and biotic filters interact with each other. •Introduced and native bees had heterogeneous responses to environmental conditions.•High temperatures caused decreased co-occurrence and increased dominance.•The opposite pattern was found for Vegetation Continuous Fields.•Co-occurrence increased as native and introduced species become more abundant.•A high dominance of introduced bees was found in unsuitable habitats.