The ‘not-so-healthy’ appearance pursuit? Disentangling unique associations of female drive for toned muscularity with disordered eating and compulsive exercise

• Published in: Body image 2022-09, Vol.42, p.276-286
• Main Authors: Cunningham, Mitchell L., Pinkus, Rebecca T., Lavender, Jason M., Rodgers, Rachel F., Mitchison, Deborah, Trompeter, Nora, Ganson, Kyle T., Nagata, Jason M., Szabo, Marianna, Murray, Stuart B., Griffiths, Scott
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Body image; Compulsive exercise; Disordered eating; Eating disorders; Female drive for muscularity; Toned muscularity; Women
• ISSN: 1740-1445; 1873-6807
• DOI: 10.1016/j.bodyim.2022.06.002

Today, many women are driven to subscribe to a more athletically oriented appearance ideal hallmarked by muscle tone (referred to as athletic- or fit-looking). However, the constellation of unhealthy eating and exercise behaviors that may accompany the pursuit of toned muscularity among women is not yet well characterized. To address this knowledge gap, our study evaluated the associations among the female drive for toned muscularity and both thinness-oriented disordered eating behaviors (e.g., dietary restriction) and muscularity-oriented disordered eating behaviors (e.g., excessive scrutiny of macro-nutrient values of food), as well as dimensions of compulsive exercise. Participants were 388 Australian undergraduate women who completed an online questionnaire including self-report measures of said constructs. Hierarchical regression models were used to determine whether the drive for toned muscularity accounted for unique variance in eating and exercise behaviors after adjusting for theoretically relevant covariates. Results indicated independent relationships between the drive for toned muscularity and several facets of thinness- and muscularity-oriented disordered eating, as well as compulsive exercise (e.g., exercise rigidity). Our findings further contribute to an emerging literature illustrating that women driven to attain a toned appearance may be vulnerable to engaging in a wide range of maladaptive eating and exercise practices. •We tested associations of female drive for muscularity with unhealthy eating and exercise.•Female drive for muscularity is linked to several indices of disordered eating.•Female drive for muscularity is linked to several indices of compulsive exercise.•Relationships with compulsive exercise were particularly salient.