Climate-associated risks for reliability, resilience, vulnerability and sustainability of irrigation reservoirs in small ungauged watersheds

• Published in: Catena (Giessen) 2024-01, Vol.234, p.107632, Article 107632
• Main Authors: Junaid Ahmad, Mirza, Sook Choi, Kyung
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: agricultural reservoirs; performance indices; sustainability; water balance
• ISSN: 0341-8162; 1872-6887
• DOI: 10.1016/j.catena.2023.107632

[Display omitted] •Performance indices were derived for 400 agricultural reservoirs in South Korea.•Small to medium-sized reservoirs were at higher risk of performance loss.•Failure events mostly occurred during the transplanting stage of rice production.•The least sustainable reservoirs had a watershed-to-irrigated area ratio ≤ 5.•Upsizing storage capacity was not feasible for all reservoirs. Climate change poses an existential threat to the functional integrity of the network of agricultural reservoirs responsible for sustaining rice production in South Korea. Anthropogenic interventions have triggered a cycle of droughts and floods by magnifying the already existing supply-demand gap, which is seriously hampering reservoir performance. The watersheds of most agricultural reservoirs in South Korea are ungauged, and inflow and outflow data are not measured. In this study, recorded volumetric water storage data from five reservoirs were used to derive observed inflow data based on the hydrological reasoning and reservoir operation rule curves. These data were then used to evaluate the performance of a lumped rainfall-runoff model in simulating the runoff generated in upstream ungauged watersheds. A water balance analysis was conducted for 400 major agricultural reservoirs spread throughout the country during 1973–2017. Performance indices were estimated based on inflow availability in the reservoirs and downstream irrigation demands. Empirical relationships were derived to predict performance indices by using the reservoirs’ physical characteristics as input variables. Generally, reservoirs received substantially higher inflows compared to irrigation demands, suggesting sufficient water availability during the rice growing season (Apr−Sep). An out-of-phase cycle of peak inflow generation and water demand periods induced frequent failure events during the rice nursery transplanting period (May−Jun), and reservoir sustainability was minimal in these months. Southern and southwestern major agricultural regions with a higher density of small- to medium-sized reservoirs would be at higher risk of climate-induced water scarcity. Upsizing storage capacity could alleviate the water deficit in reservoirs associated with watersheds featuring higher means and lower standard deviations of runoff. A watershed-to-irrigated area ratio > 5 indicated acceptable reservoir sustainability.