Framed field experiment on resource scarcity & extraction: Path-dependent generosity within sequential water appropriation

• Published in: Ecological economics 2015-12, Vol.120, p.416-429
• Main Authors: Pfaff, Alexander, Vélez, Maria Alejandra, Ramos, Pablo Andres, Molina, Adriana
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• ISSN: 0921-8009; 1873-6106
• DOI: 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2015.06.002

How one treats others is important within collective action. We ask if resource scarcity in the past, due to its effects upon past behaviors, influences current other-regarding behaviors. Contrasting theories and empirical findings on scarcity motivate our framed field experiment. Participants are rural Colombian farmers who have experienced scarcity of water within irrigation. We randomly assign participants to groups and places on group canals. Places order extraction decisions. Our treatments are sequences of scarcities: ‘from lower to higher resources' involves four rounds each of 20, 60, then 100 units of water; ‘from higher to lower resources' reverses the ordering. We find that upstream farmers extract more, but a lower share, when facing higher resources. Further they take a larger share of higher resources when they faced lower resources in earlier rounds (relative to when facing higher resources initially). That is inconsistent with leading models of responses to scarcity which focus upon one's own gain. It is consistent with lowering one's weight on others to, for instance, rationalize having left them little. Our results suggest that facing higher scarcity can erode the bases for collective actions. For establishing new institutions, timing relative to scarcity could affect the probability of success. •We look for durable effects of past resource scarcity via effects on past behaviors•We implemented a novel framed field experiment with farmers from rural Colombia•Our treatments are orderings of scarcities, higher to lower versus lower to higher•Upstream takes a larger share of higher resources if they have faced low resources•Worse for downstream, this triggers more extraction by midstream following upstream