Vertical patterns of phosphorus concentration and speciation in three forest soil profiles of contrasting climate

• Published in: Geochimica et cosmochimica acta 2021-10, Vol.310, p.1-18
• Main Authors: Zhang, Zhuojun, Zhao, Zhiqi, Liu, Congqiang, Chadwick, Oliver A., Liang, Chao, Hu, Yongfeng, Vaughan, Karen L., Zhu, Mengqiang
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Climate; Concentration and availability; Phosphorus speciation; Soil profiles; Vertical patterns; XANES spectroscopy
• ISSN: 0016-7037; 1872-9533
• DOI: 10.1016/j.gca.2021.07.002

Phosphorus (P) availability in soils controls critical functions and properties of terrestrial ecosystems. Vertical distribution patterns of P concentration and speciation in soil profiles provide historical records of how pedogenic processes redistribute and transform P and thus change its availability in soils, which, however, remain poorly understood. We determined the patterns in three forest soil profiles of contrasting climate, using fine sampling intervals, P K-edge X-ray absorption near edge (XANES) spectroscopy and chemical extractions. The major features of the patterns persist under the contrasting climate. The total P concentration decreases from A to B horizons, reaches a minimum in the B horizons, and then increases towards the upper C horizons, but with little variations with depth in the lower C horizons. Both calcium-bound inorganic P (Ca–Pi) and organic P (Po) decrease and Fe- and Al-bound Pi [(Fe + Al)–Pi] increases in proportion downward in the A horizons because dust inputs and accumulation of organic matter both decline with increasing depth. Ca–Pi is negligible and (Fe + Al)–Pi is dominant in the B horizons due to strong weathering. There is a strong downward increase in Ca–Pi proportion and decrease in (Fe + Al)–Pi proportion from the lower B to the upper C horizons. New Ca–Pi seems to form in the upper C horizons where downward leaching Ca2+ and phosphate accumulate due to the low water permeability of the soils. In the lower C horizons, Ca–Pi increases and (Fe + Al)–Pi decreases with increasing depth due to decreasing chemical weathering. Regarding P bioavailability, the proportion of occluded P (Pocc) shows an increasing and decreasing trend with increasing depth, being the highest in the B horizons; however, there are no consistent trends for non-occluded P (Pn-occ). While the P vertical patterns can be understood by considering the relative importance of different pedogenic processes, climate affects the intensities of these processes and thus the details of the patterns. When depth-integrated, warmer/wetter climate results in decreases in the proportions of both Ca–Pi and Pn-occ but increases in the P loss and the proportions of Po, (Fe + Al)–Pi, and Pocc. Regardless of soil depth and climate, the Pi speciation, i.e., the relative proportions of Ca–Pi and (Fe + Al)–Pi over total Pi, correlates well with soil pH and weathering degree (Chemical Index of Alteration, CIA), and the Po concentration correlates with pedogenic Fe and