The production-protection nexus: How political-economic processes influence prospects for transformative change in human-wildlife interactions

• Published in: Global environmental change 2023-09, Vol.82, p.102723, Article 102723
• Main Authors: Fletcher, Robert, Massarella, Kate, Ferraz, Katia M.P.M.B., Kiwango, Wilhelm A., Komi, Sanna, Mabele, Mathew B., Marchini, Silvio, Nygren, Anja, Sandroni, Laila T., Alagona, Peter S., McInturff, Alex
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Apex predators; Coexistence; Human-wildlife conflict; Human-wildlife interactions; Political economy; Transformation
• ISSN: 0959-3780
• DOI: 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2023.102723

•We develop an original analysis of the political economy of human-wildlife interaction.•We introduce a novel conceptualization of a “production-protection nexus”.•We demonstrate the importance of “unmaking” political-economic structures.•We develop comparative analysis of global north and global south cases. This article advances a novel analytical framework for investigating the influence of political-economic processes in human-wildlife interactions (HWI) to support efforts to transform wildlife conservation governance. To date, the majority of research and advocacy addressing HWI focuses on micro-level processes, while even the small body of existing literature exploring social dimensions of such interactions has largely neglected attention to political-economic forces. This is consonant with efforts to transform conservation policy and practice more broadly, which tend to emphasize “circular” change within current political-economic structures rather than “axial” transformation aiming to transcend these structures themselves. Our analysis thus advances understanding of potential for axial transformation in HWI via confrontation with, and “unmaking” of, constraining political-economic structures. It does so through cross-site analysis of conservation policy and practice in relation to three apex predator species (lions, jaguars and wolves) in varied geographic and socio-political contexts, grounded in qualitative ethnographic study within the different sites by members of an international research team. We explore how the relative power of different political-economic interests within each case influences how the animals are perceived and valued, and how this in turn influences conservation interventions and their impact on HWI within these spaces. We term this analysis of the “production-protection nexus” (the interrelation between process of resource extraction and conservation, respectively) in rural landscapes. We emphasize importance of attention to this formative nexus both within and across specific locales in growing global efforts to transform situations of human-wildlife conflict into less contentious coexistence.