Analysing ability grouping in secondary school: A way to improve academic performance and mitigate educational inequalities in Spain?

• Published in: International journal of educational development 2024-05, Vol.107, p.103028, Article 103028
• Main Authors: Blanco-Varela, Bruno, Amoedo, José Manuel, Sánchez-Carreira, María Carmen
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Ability grouping; Educational economics; Educational inequalities; Efficiency; Propensity score matching; Socio-educational vulnerability
• ISSN: 0738-0593; 1873-4871
• DOI: 10.1016/j.ijedudev.2024.103028

Socio-educational vulnerability refers to the circumstances in which students face difficulties or challenges arising from socio-economic or contextual factors, such as a lack of resources or adverse family environments. Ability grouping during secondary school is widely used to improve student performance. The methodology tailored to students performance levels aims at providing improvements in their scores. This paper explores the complex relationship between ability grouping and socio-educational vulnerability. More specifically, it investigates how different student groups are affected by attending schools that implement ability grouping as compared to those that do not. The study is conducted in Spain, using the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) database and Propensity Score Matching methodology. The findings suggest that the ability grouping policy hinder equal opportunities for academically disadvantaged students, resulting in decreasing their abilities. •Improving the quality of education systems is achieved through policies focused on efficiency and equity.•Ability grouping reduces average performance and, therefore, the efficiency of the system.•Ability grouping reduces equity in the education system,being students from the most vulnerable socio-educational backgrounds the most harmed.•Measures to improve the education system should focus on reducing material inequalities and supporting families.•The peer effect can be an educational measure that improves performance, especially by boosting low-performing students.