Policy and legislative barriers to close water-related loops in innovative small water and wastewater systems in Europe: A critical analysis

• Published in: Journal of cleaner production 2021-03, Vol.288, p.125604, Article 125604
• Main Authors: Cipolletta, Giulia, Ozbayram, Emine Gozde, Eusebi, Anna Laura, Akyol, Çağrı, Malamis, Simos, Mino, Eric, Fatone, Francesco
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Environmental policy; Innovation; Non-conventional water resource; Reclaimed water reuse; Rural area; Sustainability
• ISSN: 0959-6526; 1879-1786
• DOI: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.125604

Water supply and reuse through non-conventional water resources can significantly decrease the stress on natural water resources. Decentralized systems can help not only to alleviate issues of water security in arid areas, but also to create a sustainable framework within a circular economy. Although these small-scale innovative technologies are able to achieve ready-to-use, high quality of recovered/treated water on-site, the loop cannot be closed in most cases due to legislative barriers. Similarly, the end-use of sewage sludge after treatment in decentralized systems still lacks specific regulations that limit its valorization. This work analyzes the current policy and legislations related to water supply, wastewater treatment, water reuse and resource valorization within the context of decentralized state-of-the-art technologies applied in rural areas. The drawbacks in the current EU legislation that set barriers to close water-related loops in European countries are highlighted. A regulatory fitness check was applied to each type of loop to identify the key factors to accomplish the legislative compliance, and financing pathways were further evaluated at the EU level. As a possible solution, further development of an innovation deal approach is recommended to address the environmental, regulatory and financial gaps in water management through an integrated framework, providing ad-hoc policies and prescriptions for sustainable reuse of all water resources. •Regulatory fitness check was applied to closed water loops to identify legislative and financing barriers.•Current EU legislatives do not provide ad-hoc guidelines to decentralized systems.•No general barriers were detected for the reuse of reclaimed water in the EU legislation.•Serious limitations exist on drinking water production from non-conventional water resources.•Major constraints were determined for EC-marked compost for organic farming.