Examining greenwashing and SDG-washing: an analysis of corporate engagement with the SDGs

• Published in: Sustainability accounting, management and policy journal (Print) management and policy journal (Print), 2024-02, Vol.15 (2), p.412-456
• Main Authors: del Río, Cristina, González-Álvarez, Karen, López-Arceiz, Francisco José
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Accountability; Collaboration; Competition; Compliance; Cooperation; Design; False information; Greenwashing; Literature reviews; Stakeholders; Sustainable development
• ISSN: 2040-8021; 2040-8021; 2040-803X
• DOI: 10.1108/SAMPJ-02-2023-0080

Purpose The purpose of this study is to examine the existence of greenwashing and sustainable development goal (SDG)-washing processes by comparing ex ante (SDG Compass) and ex post (SDG Compliance) indicators and investigating whether the limitations associated with these indicators encourage companies to engage in washing processes. Design/methodology/approach The authors use a sample of 1,154 companies included in the S&P Sustainability Yearbook (formerly the RobecoSAM Yearbook). The authors test for the presence of greenwashing by comparing ex ante and ex post indicators for each SDG, whereas to test for SDG-washing, the authors compare the two ex ante and ex post approaches considering the full set of SDGs. Findings The results show that there is no consistency between the two types of indicators to measure the level of SDG implementation in organisations. This lack of consistency may facilitate both greenwashing and SDG-washing processes, which is due to the design and limitations of these measurement tools. Practical implications Companies may choose those indicators that paint their commitment to the SDGs in the best light, but they may also select indicators based on the SDGs they want to report on. These two options would combine greenwashing and SDG-washing. Social implications The shift towards improved standards and regulations for measuring SDG achievement is the result of several social factors such as investor scrutiny, regulatory reform, consumer awareness and increased corporate accountability. Originality/value Few previous studies have analysed in detail the interaction between greenwashing and SDG-washing. They focus on the use of ex ante or ex post indicators separately, with samples composed of local companies, and without considering the whole set of SDGs.