Expert knowledge elicitation for decision-making in home energy retrofits

• Published in: Structural survey 2014-11, Vol.32 (5), p.377-395
• Main Authors: Yaw Addai Duah, Daniel, Ford, Kevin, Syal, Matt
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Building & construction; Climate change; Computers; Decision making; Decision support systems; Energy efficiency; Environmental protection; Expert systems; Experts; Green buildings; Homeowners; Human performance; Knowledge; Organizational change; Project management; Property management & built environment; Psychology; Tacit knowledge
• ISSN: 0263-080X; 2398-4708; 1758-6844; 2398-4716
• DOI: 10.1108/SS-01-2014-0004

Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to develop a knowledge elicitation strategy to elicit and compile home energy retrofit knowledge that can be incorporated into the development of an intelligent decision support system to help increase the uptake of home energy retrofits. Major problems accounting for low adoption rates despite well-established benefits are: lack of information or information in unsuitable and usable format for decision making by homeowners. Despite the important role of expert knowledge in developing such systems, its elicitation has been fraught with challenges. Design/methodology/approach – Using extensive literature review and a Delphi-dominated data collection technique, the relevant knowledge of 19 industry experts, selected based on previously developed determinants of expert knowledge and suitable for decision making was elicited and compiled. Boolean logic was used to model and represent such knowledge for use as an intelligent decision support system. Findings – A combination of comprehensive knowledge elicitor training, Delphi technique, semi-structured interview, and job shadowing is a good elicitation strategy. It encourages experts to describe their knowledge in a natural way, relate to specific problems, and reduces bias. Relevant and consensus-based expert knowledge can be incorporated into the development of an intelligent decision support system. Research limitations/implications – The consensus-based and relevant expert knowledge can assist homeowners with decision making and industry practitioners and academia with corroboration and enhancement of existing knowledge. The strategy contributes to solving the knowledge elicitation challenge. Originality/value – No previous study regarding a knowledge elicitation strategy for developing an intelligent decision support system for the energy retrofit industry exists.