“This Land of Thorns Is Not Habitable”: Diagnosing the Despair of Racialized Meta-oppression

• Published in: Critical philosophy of race 2024-01, Vol.12 (1), p.126-144
• Main Author: Scott, Jacqueline Renée
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Anzaldua; Ethnic Studies; meta-oppression; pessimism; Philosophy; racial health; racism
• ISSN: 2165-8684; 2165-8692
• DOI: 10.5325/critphilrace.12.1.0126

This article addresses the growing literature in critical race studies, which holds that racism is permanent or incurable, and that by adopting this pessimistic view of racism, we can enact improved and healthier racialized lives. I argue that the focus on curing anti-Black racism, and the failure to do so in the civil rights era and its aftermath has left people of all races, to varying degrees, stuck in pessimistic states of racialized anger, resentment, guilt, and shame. These pessimistic states have brought about an additional level of oppression for targets of racialized oppression. I call it “meta-oppression,” and it is the oppression of being oppressed. I argue that this oppression has exacerbated the effects of the social disease of racism, and it has literally affected the physiologies of many African Americans. This article provides a diagnosis of these existential and physiological states of meta-oppression and a clarification of its characteristics. This diagnosis is an initial step in a larger project of formulating and enacting effective treatments for it. I then argue that meta-oppression is a helpful diagnostic tool for clarifying the characteristics and ramifications on Blacks of US systemic racism during the post–civil rights movement period. I aim to establish meta-oppression as an existential and physiological condition that requires attention so as to expand the social imaginations of people of color and to allow us to engage in more systemic joyful affirmations of our racialized lives while still living within racist conditions.