3GOLD: optimized Levenshtein distance for clustering third-generation sequencing data

• Published in: BMC bioinformatics 2022-03, Vol.23 (1), p.95-95, Article 95
• Main Authors: Logan, Robert, Fleischmann, Zoe, Annis, Sofia, Wehe, Amy Wangsness, Tilly, Jonathan L, Woods, Dori C, Khrapko, Konstantin
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Accuracy; Algorithms; Analysis; Biological effects; Centroids; Cluster Analysis; Clustering; Clustering (Computers); Computational biology; Computer applications; Datasets; DNA sequencing; Edit-distance; Experiments; Expressed sequence tags; High-Throughput Nucleotide Sequencing; Methods; Next-generation sequencing; Nucleotide sequencing; Sensitivity; Sequence Analysis, DNA; Sequences; Single-molecule sequencing
• ISSN: 1471-2105; 1471-2105
• DOI: 10.1186/s12859-022-04637-7

Third-generation sequencing offers some advantages over next-generation sequencing predecessors, but with the caveat of harboring a much higher error rate. Clustering-related sequences is an essential task in modern biology. To accurately cluster sequences rich in errors, error type and frequency need to be accounted for. Levenshtein distance is a well-established mathematical algorithm for measuring the edit distance between words and can specifically weight insertions, deletions and substitutions. However, there are drawbacks to using Levenshtein distance in a biological context and hence has rarely been used for this purpose. We present novel modifications to the Levenshtein distance algorithm to optimize it for clustering error-rich biological sequencing data. We successfully introduced a bidirectional frameshift allowance with end-user determined accommodation caps combined with weighted error discrimination. Furthermore, our modifications dramatically improved the computational speed of Levenstein distance. For simulated ONT MinION and PacBio Sequel datasets, the average clustering sensitivity for 3GOLD was 41.45% (S.D. 10.39) higher than Sequence-Levenstein distance, 52.14% (S.D. 9.43) higher than Levenshtein distance, 55.93% (S.D. 8.67) higher than Starcode, 42.68% (S.D. 8.09) higher than CD-HIT-EST and 61.49% (S.D. 7.81) higher than DNACLUST. For biological ONT MinION data, 3GOLD clustering sensitivity was 27.99% higher than Sequence-Levenstein distance, 52.76% higher than Levenshtein distance, 56.39% higher than Starcode, 48% higher than CD-HIT-EST and 70.4% higher than DNACLUST. Our modifications to Levenshtein distance have improved its speed and accuracy compared to the classic Levenshtein distance, Sequence-Levenshtein distance and other commonly used clustering approaches on simulated and biological third-generation sequenced datasets. Our clustering approach is appropriate for datasets of unknown cluster centroids, such as those generated with unique molecular identifiers as well as known centroids such as barcoded datasets. A strength of our approach is high accuracy in resolving small clusters and mitigating the number of singletons.