Challenges to effective and autonomous genetic testing and counseling for ethno-cultural minorities: a qualitative study

• Published in: BMC medical ethics 2020-10, Vol.21 (1), p.98-98, Article 98
• Main Authors: Cohen-Kfir, Nehama, Bentwich, Miriam Ethel, Kent, Andrew, Dickman, Nomy, Tanus, Mary, Higazi, Basem, Kalfon, Limor, Rudolf, Mary, Falik-Zaccai, Tzipora C
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Abortion; Arab minorities; Bioethics; Birth defects; Christians; Clinics; Counseling services; Cultural competence; Culture; Empowerment; Ethno-cultural minority; Focus groups; Genetic counseling; Genetic counseling barriers; Genetic testing; Genetics; Interviews; Medical ethics; Minority & ethnic groups; Multicultural society; Multiculturalism & pluralism; Muslims; Nurses; Population; Prenatal genetic testing; Qualitative research; Religion; Womens health
• ISSN: 1472-6939; 1472-6939
• DOI: 10.1186/s12910-020-00537-8

The Arab population in Israel is a minority ethnic group with its own distinct cultural subgroups. Minority populations are known to underutilize genetic tests and counseling services, thereby undermining the effectiveness of these services among such populations. However, the general and culture-specific reasons for this underutilization are not well defined. Moreover, Arab populations and their key cultural-religious subsets (Muslims, Christians, and Druze) do not reside exclusively in Israel, but are rather found as a minority group in many European and North American countries. Therefore, focusing on the Arab population in Israel allows for the examination of attitudes regarding genetic testing and counseling among this globally important ethnic minority population. We used a qualitative research method, employing individual interviews with 18 women of childbearing age from three religious subgroups (i.e., Druze, Muslim, and Christian) who reside in the Acre district, along with focus group discussions with healthcare providers (HCPs; 9 nurses and 7 genetic counselors) working in the same geographical district. A general lack of knowledge regarding the goals and practice of genetic counseling resulting in negative preconceptions of genetic testing was identified amongst all counselees. Counselors' objective of respecting patient autonomy in decision-making, together with counselees' misunderstanding of genetic risk data, caused uncertainty, frustration, and distrust. In addition, certain interesting variations were found between the different religious subgroups regarding their attitudes to genetic counseling. The study highlights the miscommunications between HCPs, particularly counselors from the majority ethno-cultural group, and counselees from a minority ethno-cultural group. The need for nuanced understanding of the complex perspectives of minority ethno-cultural groups is also emphasized. Such an understanding may enhance the effectiveness of genetic testing and counseling among the Arab minority group while also genuinely empowering the personal autonomy of counselees from this minority group in Israel and other countries.