Developing an Evidence and Theory Based Multimodal Integrative Intervention for the Management of Renal Cachexia: A Theory of Change

• Published in: Healthcare (Basel) 2022-11, Vol.10 (12), p.2344
• Main Authors: Blair, Carolyn, Slee, Adrian, Davenport, Andrew, Fouque, Denis, Johnston, William, Kalantar-Zadeh, Kamyar, Maxwell, Peter, McKeaveney, Clare, Mullan, Robert, Noble, Helen, Porter, Sam, Seres, David, Shields, Joanne, Swaine, Ian, Witham, Miles, Reid, Joanne
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Animal biology; Anti-inflammatory agents; Cachexia; Cancer; Care and treatment; Collaboration; Costs; Counseling; Diagnosis; end-stage kidney disease; Evaluation; Evidence-based medicine; Intervention; kidney disease; Kidney diseases; Life Sciences; Literature reviews; Metabolism; Methods; Mortality; Nephrology; Nutrition; Nutritional status; Patients; personal and public involvement; Quality of life; renal disease; Stakeholders; Systematic review; theory of change
• ISSN: 2227-9032; 2227-9032
• DOI: 10.3390/healthcare10122344

In this study, we aimed to develop a theoretical framework for a multimodal, integrative, exercise, anti-inflammatory and dietary counselling (MMIEAD) intervention for patients with renal cachexia with reference to how this addresses the underlying causal pathways for renal cachexia, the outcomes anticipated, and how these will be evaluated. We used a Theory of Change (ToC) approach to guide six steps. Step 1 included inputs from a workshop to obtain key stakeholder views on the potential development of a multimodal intervention for renal cachexia. Step 2 included the findings of a mixed-methods study with Health Care Practitioners (HCPs) caring for individuals with End Stage Kidney Disease (ESKD) and cachexia. Step 3 included the results from our systematic literature review on multimodal interventions for cachexia management. In step 4, we used the body of our research team's cachexia research and wider relevant research to gather evidence on the specific components of the multimodal intervention with reference to how this addresses the underlying causal pathways for renal cachexia. In steps 5 and 6 we developed and refined the ToC map in consultation with the core research team and key stakeholders which illustrates how the intervention components of MMIEAD interact to achieve the intended long-term outcomes and anticipated impact. The results of this study provide a theoretical framework for the forthcoming MMIEAD intervention for those with renal cachexia and in subsequent phases will be used to determine whether this intervention is effective. To the best of our knowledge no other multimodal intervention trials for cachexia management have reported a ToC. Therefore, this research may provide a useful framework and contribute to the ongoing development of interventions for cachexia management.