Variability of Muscle Synergies in Hand Grasps: Analysis of Intra- and Inter-Session Data

• Published in: Sensors (Basel, Switzerland) Switzerland), 2020-08, Vol.20 (15), p.4297
• Main Authors: Pale, Una, Atzori, Manfredo, Müller, Henning, Scano, Alessandro
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Activities of Daily Living; Adult; Assessments; Biomechanical Phenomena; Central nervous system; Coefficient of variation; Correlation analysis; Datasets; Electrodes; Electromyography; Female; Hand; hand grasps; Hand Strength; Humans; inter-session; intra-session; Male; muscle synergies; Muscle, Skeletal; Muscles; Patients; Recording equipment; Similarity; Stability analysis; variability; virtual electrode repositioning; Young Adult
• ISSN: 1424-8220; 1424-8220
• DOI: 10.3390/s20154297

Muscle synergy analysis is an approach to understand the neurophysiological mechanisms behind the hypothesized ability of the Central Nervous System (CNS) to reduce the dimensionality of muscle control. The muscle synergy approach is also used to evaluate motor recovery and the evolution of the patients' motor performance both in single-session and longitudinal studies. Synergy-based assessments are subject to various sources of variability: natural trial-by-trial variability of performed movements, intrinsic characteristics of subjects that change over time (e.g., recovery, adaptation, exercise, etc.), as well as experimental factors such as different electrode positioning. These sources of variability need to be quantified in order to resolve challenges for the application of muscle synergies in clinical environments. The objective of this study is to analyze the stability and similarity of extracted muscle synergies under the effect of factors that may induce variability, including inter- and intra-session variability within subjects and inter-subject variability differentiation. The analysis was performed using the comprehensive, publicly available hand grasp NinaPro Database, featuring surface electromyography (EMG) measures from two EMG electrode bracelets. Intra-session, inter-session, and inter-subject synergy stability was analyzed using the following measures: variance accounted for (VAF) and number of synergies (NoS) as measures of reconstruction stability quality and cosine similarity for comparison of spatial composition of extracted synergies. Moreover, an approach based on virtual electrode repositioning was applied to shed light on the influence of electrode position on inter-session synergy similarity. Inter-session synergy similarity was significantly lower with respect to intra-session similarity, both considering coefficient of variation of VAF (approximately 0.2-15% for inter vs. approximately 0.1% to 2.5% for intra, depending on NoS) and coefficient of variation of NoS (approximately 6.5-14.5% for inter vs. approximately 3-3.5% for intra, depending on VAF) as well as synergy similarity (approximately 74-77% for inter vs. approximately 88-94% for intra, depending on the selected VAF). Virtual electrode repositioning revealed that a slightly different electrode position can lower similarity of synergies from the same session and can increase similarity between sessions. Finally, the similarity of inter-subject synergies has no significa