Assessing the Relationship Between Digital Trail Making Test Performance and IT Task Performance: Empirical Study

• Published in: JMIR human factors 2024-06, Vol.11, p.e49992
• Main Authors: Depauw, Tanguy, Boasen, Jared, Léger, Pierre-Majorique, Sénécal, Sylvain
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Adult; Automation; Cognition - physiology; Cognitive ability; Empirical Research; Executive function; Experiments; Female; Human-computer interaction; Humans; Information systems; Male; Memory; Pictographs; Reproducibility of Results; Task Performance and Analysis; Trail Making Test; Usability; Visual perception
• ISSN: 2292-9495; 2292-9495
• DOI: 10.2196/49992

Cognitive functional ability affects the accessibility of IT and is thus something that should be controlled for in user experience (UX) research. However, many cognitive function assessment batteries are long and complex, making them impractical for use in conventional experimental time frames. Therefore, there is a need for a short and reliable cognitive assessment that has discriminant validity for cognitive functions needed for general IT tasks. One potential candidate is the Trail Making Test (TMT). This study investigated the usefulness of a digital TMT as a cognitive profiling tool in IT-related UX research by assessing its predictive validity on general IT task performance and exploring its discriminant validity according to discrete cognitive functions required to perform the IT task. A digital TMT (parts A and B) named Axon was administered to 27 healthy participants, followed by administration of 5 IT tasks in the form of CAPTCHAs (Completely Automated Public Turing tests to Tell Computers and Humans Apart). The discrete cognitive functions required to perform each CAPTCHA were rated by trained evaluators. To further explain and cross-validate our results, the original TMT and 2 psychological assessments of visuomotor and short-term memory function were administered. Axon A and B were administrable in less than 5 minutes, and overall performance was significantly predictive of general IT task performance (F =6.352; P=.001; Λ=0.374). This result was driven by performance on Axon B (F =3.382; P=.02; Λ=0.529), particularly for IT tasks involving the combination of executive processing with visual object and pattern recognition. Furthermore, Axon was cross-validated with the original TMT (P =.001 and P =.017 for A and B, respectively) and visuomotor and short-term memory tasks. The results demonstrate that variance in IT task performance among an age-homogenous neurotypical population can be related to intersubject variance in cognitive function as assessed by Axon. Although Axon's predictive validity seemed stronger for tasks involving the combination of executive function with visual object and pattern recognition, these cognitive functions are arguably relevant to the majority of IT interfaces. Considering its short administration time and remote implementability, the Axon digital TMT demonstrates the potential to be a useful cognitive profiling tool for IT-based UX research.