Complexities and benefits of adopting next-generation sequencing-based tuberculosis diagnostics: a qualitative study among stakeholders in low and high-income countries

• Published in: BMJ open 2023-04, Vol.13 (4), p.e066651-e066651
• Main Authors: Grandjean Lapierre, Simon, Nouvet, Elysée, Boutin, Catherine-Audrey, Rabodoarivelo, Marie-Sylvianne, Mahboob, Omar, Smith, Maxwell J, Rakotosamimanana, Niaina
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Canada; COVID-19; Developed Countries; diagnostic microbiology; Diagnostics; Disease transmission; Drug resistance; High-Throughput Nucleotide Sequencing; Humans; Laboratories; Medical diagnosis; Qualitative Research; Tuberculosis; Tuberculosis - diagnosis
• ISSN: 2044-6055; 2044-6055
• DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2022-066651

ObjectivesTo clarify perceived benefits, barriers and facilitators of Mycobacterium tuberculosis next-generation sequencing implementation in Madagascar and Canada, towards informing implementation of this diagnostic technology in public health agencies and clinical settings in and beyond these settings.DesignThis qualitative study involved conducting semistructured interviews with key stakeholders engaged with next-generation sequencing implementation in Madagascar and Canada. Team-based descriptive analysis supported by Nvivo V.12.0 was used to identify key themes.SettingThe study was conducted with participants involved at the clinical, diagnostic and surveillance levels of tuberculosis (TB) management from Madagascar and Canada.ParticipantsEighteen participants were interviewed (nine Madagascar and nine Canada) and included individuals purposively sampled based on involvement with TB surveillance, laboratory diagnosis and clinical management.ResultsThe following five themes emerged in the analysis of Malagasy and Canadian interviews: (1) heterogeneity in experience with established TB diagnostics, (2) variable understanding of new sequencing-based diagnostics potential; (3) further evidence as being key to expand adoption; (4) ethical arguments and concerns; (5) operational and system-level considerations.ConclusionThere persists important lack of familiarity with TB next-generation sequencing (TB NGS) applications among stakeholders in Canada and Madagascar. This translates into skepticism on the evidence underlying its use and its true potential value added within global public health systems. If deployed, TB NGS testing should be integrated with clinical and surveillance programmes. Although this is perceived as a priority, leadership and funding responsibilities for this integration to happen remains unclear to clinical, laboratory and public health stakeholders.