Navigating ethics in HIV data and biomaterial management within Black, African, and Caribbean communities in Canada

• Published in: BMC medical ethics 2025-01, Vol.26 (1), p.5-9, Article 5
• Main Authors: Souleymanov, Rusty, Akinyele-Akanbi, Bolaji, Njeze, Chinyere, Ukoli, Patricia, Migliardi, Paula, Larcombe, Linda, Restall, Gayle, Ringaert, Laurie, Payne, Michael, Kim, John, Tharao, Wangari, Wilcox, Ayn
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Adult; Africa; Black People; Canada; Caribbean Region; Collaboration; Community; Community-Based Participatory Research - ethics; Confidentiality - ethics; Consent; Criminalization; Data analysis; Data collection; Epidemics; Ethical concerns; Ethical considerations; Female; Health data; HIV; HIV community-based testing; HIV Infections - therapy; HIV Testing - ethics; Human immunodeficiency virus; Human rights; Humans; Immigration; Informed Consent - ethics; Male; Manitoba; Medical ethics; Medical research; Medical tests; Middle Aged; Privacy; Public health; Qualitative Research; Racial profiling; Reporting requirements; Research ethics; Secondary use of biomaterials; Surveillance; Young Adult
• ISSN: 1472-6939; 1472-6939
• DOI: 10.1186/s12910-025-01161-0

This study explored the ethical issues associated with community-based HIV testing among African, Caribbean, and Black (ACB) populations in Canada, focusing on their perceptions of consent, privacy, and the management of HIV-related data and bio-samples. A qualitative community-based participatory research (CBPR) approach was employed to actively engage ACB community members in shaping the research process. The design included in-depth qualitative interviews with 33 ACB community members in Manitoba, Canada. The study was guided by a Community Guiding Circle, which contributed to study design, data analysis, and interpretation. A diverse sample was recruited through community agencies, social media, and flyers, with considerations for variations in age, gender, sexual orientation, and geographical location. The study employed iterative inductive thematic data analysis. Participants expressed significant concerns about the collection, sharing, and use of HIV data from healthcare encounters, revealing mistrust towards institutions like police, child welfare, and immigration accessing their health information. Their worries centered on the handling of biological samples, data misuse, potential human rights violations, HIV criminalization, deportations, challenging consent, privacy, and bodily autonomy principles. While open to contributing to medical research, they unanimously demanded greater transparency, informed consent, and control over the secondary use of their health data. The study underscores the need for culturally safe approaches in HIV testing and ethical governance in healthcare for ACB communities. It highlights the importance of prioritizing participant empowerment, ensuring transparency, practicing informed consent, and implementing robust data security measures to balance effective HIV information management with the protection of individual rights.