Live donor kidney transplantation. Situation analysis and roadmap

• Published in: Nefrología 2022-01, Vol.42 (1), p.85-93
• Main Authors: de la Oliva Valentín, María, Hernández, Domingo, Crespo, Marta, Mahillo, Beatriz, Beneyto, Isabel, Martínez, Itziar, Kanter, Julia, Calderari, Elena, Gil-Vernet, Salvador, Sánchez, Sara, Agüera, Maria Luisa, Bernal, Gabriel, de Santiago, Carlos, Díaz-Corte, Carmen, Díaz, Cándido, Espinosa, Laura, Facundo, Carme, Fernández-Lucas, Milagros, Ferreiro, Tamara, García-Erauzkin, Gorka, García-Alvarez, Teresa, Fraile, Pilar, González-Rinne, Ana, González-Soriano, María José, González, Esther, Gutiérrez-Dalmau, Alex, Jiménez, Carlos, Lauzurica, Ricardo, Lorenzo, Inmaculada, Martín-Moreno, Paloma L., Moreso, Francesc, de Gracia, María Carmen, Pérez-Flores, Isabel, Ramos-Verde, Ana, Revuelta, Ignacio, Rodríguez-Ferrero, María Luisa, Ruiz, Juan Carlos, Sánchez-Sobrino, Beatriz, Domínguez-Gil, Beatriz
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Autoevaluación del proceso de donación de vivo; Benchmarking; Chronic kidney disease treatment; Evolución donación de vivo; Living donation evolution; Living donation process; Living donor kidney transplantation; Optimización de la donación de vivo; Optimization of living kidney donation; Proceso de donación de vivo; Self-assessment of the living donation process; Trasplante renal de donante vivo; Tratamiento de la enfermedad renal crónica avanzada
• ISSN: 2013-2514; 2013-2514
• DOI: 10.1016/j.nefroe.2022.02.002

Living donor kidney transplantation (LDKT) is the best treatment option for end stage renal disease in terms of both patient and graft survival. However, figures on LDKT in Spain that had been continuously growing from 2005 to 2014, have experienced a continuous decrease in the last five years. One possible explanation for this decrease is that the significant increase in the number of deceased donors in Spain during the last years, both brain death and controlled circulatory death donors, might have generated the false idea that we have coped with the transplant needs. Moreover, a greater number of deceased donor kidney transplants have caused a heavy workload for the transplant teams. Furthermore, the transplant teams could have moved on to a more conservative approach to the information and assessment of patients and families considering the potential long-term risks for donors in recent papers. However, there is a significant variability in the LDKT rate among transplant centers and regions in Spain independent of their deceased donor rates. This fact and the fact that LDKT is usually a preemptive option for patients with advanced chronic renal failure, as time on dialysis is a negative independent factor for transplant outcomes, lead us to conclude that the decrease in LDKT depends on other factors. Thus, in the kidney transplant annual meeting held at ONT site in 2018, a working group was created to identify other causes for the decrease of LDKT in Spain and its relationship with the different steps of the process. The group was formed by transplant teams, a representative of the transplant group of the Spanish Society of Nephrology (SENTRA), a representative of the Spanish Society of Transplants (SET) and representatives of the Spanish National Transplant Organization (ONT). A self-evaluation survey that contains requests about the phases of the LDKT processes (information, donor work out, informed consent, surgeries, follow-up and human resources) were developed and sent to 33 LDKT teams. All the centers answered the questionnaire. The analysis of the answers has resulted in the creation of a national analysis of strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, threats (SWOT) of the LDKT program in Spain and the development of recommendations targeted to improve every step of the donation process. The work performed, the conclusions and recommendations provided, have been reflected in the following report: Spanish living donor kidney transplant program assess