Investigating the Potential of Sentinel-2 MSI in Early Crop Identification in Northeast China

• Published in: Remote sensing (Basel, Switzerland) Switzerland), 2022-04, Vol.14 (8), p.1928
• Main Authors: Wei, Mengfan, Wang, Hongyan, Zhang, Yuan, Li, Qiangzi, Du, Xin, Shi, Guanwei, Ren, Yiting
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Accuracy; automatic sample generation; classifier; Classifiers; Corn; Crop growth; Crop identification; Crops; Decision making; early crop identification; feature optimization; Flooding; Growth stage; historical crop maps; Optimization; Planting management; Recognition; Reliability analysis; Remote sensing; Rice; Soybeans; Time series; Vegetation; Wheat
• ISSN: 2072-4292; 2072-4292
• DOI: 10.3390/rs14081928

Early crop identification can provide timely and valuable information for agricultural planting management departments to make reasonable and correct decisions. At present, there is still a lack of systematic summary and analysis on how to obtain real-time samples in the early stage, what the optimal feature sets are, and what level of crop identification accuracy can be achieved at different stages. First, this study generated training samples with the help of historical crop maps in 2019 and remote sensing images in 2020. Then, a feature optimization method was used to obtain the optimal features in different stages. Finally, the differences of the four classifiers in identifying crops and the variation characteristics of crop identification accuracy at different stages were analyzed. These experiments were conducted at three sites in Heilongjiang Province to evaluate the reliability of the results. The results showed that the earliest identification time of corn can be obtained in early July (the seven leaves period) with an identification accuracy up to 86%. In the early stages, its accuracy was 40~79%, which was low, and could not reach the satisfied accuracy requirements. In the middle stages, a satisfactory recognition accuracy could be achieved, and its recognition accuracy was 79~100%. The late stage had a higher recognition accuracy, which was 90~100%. The accuracy of soybeans at each stage was similar to that of corn, and the earliest identification time of soybeans could also be obtained in early July (the blooming period) with an identification accuracy up to 87%. Its accuracy in the early growth stage was 35~71%; in the middle stage, it was 69~100%; and in the late stage, it was 92~100%. Unlike corn and soybeans, the earliest identification time of rice could be obtained at the end of April (the flooding period) with an identification accuracy up to 86%. In the early stage, its accuracy was 58~100%; in the middle stage, its accuracy was 93~100%; and in the late stage, its accuracy was 96~100%. In terms of crop identification accuracy in the whole growth stage, GBDT and RF performed better than other classifiers in our three study areas. This study systematically investigated the potential of early crop recognition in Northeast China, and the results are helpful for relevant applications and decision making of crop recognition in different crop growth stages.