Unravelling Humanitarian Narratives: Gender Norm Change during Displacement?

• Published in: Journal of humanitarian affairs 2022-12, Vol.4 (2), p.22-31
• Main Author: Lokot, Michelle
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Displaced persons; displacement; Empowerment; gender; Gender equity; Households; Humanitarianism; Modernity; Narratives; Neoliberalism; Norms; Power; refugee; Refugees; syria; Traditions
• ISSN: 2515-6411; 2515-6411
• DOI: 10.7227/JHA.087

International humanitarian actors, such as non-governmental organisations (NGOs) and United Nations agencies, often focus on gender norm change when conducting gender analysis among refugees and internally displaced persons. Dominant humanitarian narratives about gender in research reports, assessments and technical guidance reveal an underlying belief that displacement is causative – an external, intervening force. In such analysis, colonial and neoliberal ideologies may influence how refugees’ lives are represented, resulting in depictions of lack of modernity, tradition and culture as overarching (yet ill-defined) forces, and women and girls as vulnerable by default. Such analysis is frequently ahistorical, presented without analysis of the pre-displacement situation. This paper explores and challenges humanitarian narratives about gender norm change during displacement. It is based on feminist ethnographic research in Jordan with Syrian women and men as well as interviews with humanitarian workers. The paper demonstrates that assumptions about lack of empowerment of Syrian women and men may be misguided, identifying both subtle and more overt forms of Syrian women’s and men’s resistance’ to expected norms. It urges humanitarian actors to use ‘resistance’ as an alternative to analysing ‘change’, recognise heterogeneity within populations, resist ‘rapid’ data collection, challenge paternalistic and colonial stereotypes, and reflect complexity in analysis.