About Tree Height Measurement: Theoretical and Practical Issues for Uncertainty Quantification and Mapping

• Published in: Forests 2022-07, Vol.13 (7), p.969
• Main Authors: De Petris, Samuele, Sarvia, Filippo, Borgogno-Mondino, Enrico
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Accuracy; Carbon sequestration; Ecological research; Error analysis; Estimation; forest biomes; Forest management; Forestry; Forestry research; Forests; Google Earth Engine; hypsometer; Hypsometers; Laboratories; Lasers; Parameter sensitivity; Polls & surveys; Sensitivity analysis; Terrain; Timber; tree height uncertainty; Trees; Tropical forests; Tundra; Uncertainty; variance propagation law
• ISSN: 1999-4907; 1999-4907
• DOI: 10.3390/f13070969

Forest height is a fundamental parameter in forestry. Tree height is widely used to assess a site’s productivity both in forest ecology research and forest management. Thus, a precise height measure represents a necessary step for the estimation of carbon storage at the local, national, and global scales. In this context, error in height measurement necessarily affects the accuracy of related estimates. Ordinarily, forest height is surveyed by ground sampling adopting hypsometers. The latter suffers from many errors mainly related to the correct tree apex identification (not always well visible in dense stands) and to the measurement process itself. In this work, a statistically based operative method for estimating height measurement uncertainty (σH) was proposed using the variance propagation law. Some simulations were performed involving several combinations of terrain slope, tree height, and survey distances by modelling the σH behaviour and its sensitivity to such parameters. Results proved that σH could vary between 0.5 m and up to 20 m (worst case). Sensitivity analysis shows that terrain slopes and distance poorly affect σH, while angles are the main drivers of height uncertainty. Finally, to give a practical example of such deductions, tree height uncertainty was mapped at the global scale using Google Earth Engine and summarized per forest biomes. Results proved that tropical biomes have higher uncertainty (from 1 m to 4 m) while shrublands and tundra have the lowest (under 1 m).