Imposing ‘Enclosed Communities’? Urban Gating of Large Housing Estates in Sweden and France

Gated communities and gated housing enclaves have primarily been identified as elite spaces of privilege that support self-imposed disaffiliation and spatial and social withdrawal by the affluent. Over the past decade, however, European countries have also seen a rise of gating in large housing esta...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Published in:Land (Basel) 2023-08, Vol.12 (8), p.1535
Main Authors: Grundstrom, Karin, Lelevrier, Christine
Format: Article
Language:English
Subjects:
Comparative studies
Densification
enclosure
Enclosures
Fear of crime
France
Gated communities
Gating
Housing
Housing estates
micro-segregation
Middle class
Modernization
Neighborhoods
Parks & recreation areas
Playgrounds
Privatization
Public spaces
Sweden
urban gating
Citations: Items that this one cites
Items that cite this one
Online Access:Get full text
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
Description
Summary:Gated communities and gated housing enclaves have primarily been identified as elite spaces of privilege that support self-imposed disaffiliation and spatial and social withdrawal by the affluent. Over the past decade, however, European countries have also seen a rise of gating in large housing estates. Drawing on previous research and a comparative case study that includes interviews, observations, and mapping, this article analyses policies and practices of gating in large housing estates since 2010 in Malmö, Sweden and since 2000 in Paris, France. We argue, first, that gating is legitimised by policy arguments about ‘defensible space’, by a critique of the modernist design, and by a perceived need for diversification. Secondly, we expand the notion of urban gating and identify four types of enclosure: complete enclosure, semi-enclosure, enclosure through densification, and enclosure of parks and playgrounds. We conclude that the notion of the welfare state has changed, not only in financial terms but also as an urban form, leading to the micro-segregation of housing and land, which makes visible the social stratification within large housing estates. Gating of large housing estates thus leads to ‘enclosed communities’ rather than ‘gated communities’.
ISSN:2073-445X
2073-445X
DOI:10.3390/land12081535