A machine learning approach to small area estimation: predicting the health, housing and well-being of the population of Netherlands

• Published in: International journal of health geographics 2022-06, Vol.21 (1), p.4-4, Article 4
• Main Authors: Viljanen, Markus, Meijerink, Lotta, Zwakhals, Laurens, van de Kassteele, Jan
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Adults; Collaboration; Datasets; Estimates; Estimation; Extreme gradient boosting; Health and welfare; Housing; Institutionalization; Learning algorithms; Local population; Machine learning; Mathematical models; Missing data; Modelling; Neighborhoods; Nonlinear response; Polls & surveys; Population; Predictions; Public health; Questionnaires; Regression models; Robustness (mathematics); Small area estimation; Statistical analysis; Statistical models; Surveys; Trees; Well being
• ISSN: 1476-072X; 1476-072X
• DOI: 10.1186/s12942-022-00304-5

Local policymakers require information about public health, housing and well-being at small geographical areas. A municipality can for example use this information to organize targeted activities with the aim of improving the well-being of their residents. Surveys are often used to gather data, but many neighborhoods can have only few or even zero respondents. In that case, estimating the status of the local population directly from survey responses is prone to be unreliable. Small Area Estimation (SAE) is a technique to provide estimates at small geographical levels with only few or even zero respondents. In classical individual-level SAE, a complex statistical regression model is fitted to the survey responses by using auxiliary administrative data for the population as predictors, the missing responses are then predicted and aggregated to the desired geographical level. In this paper we compare gradient boosted trees (XGBoost), a well-known machine learning technique, to a structured additive regression model (STAR) designed for the specific problem of estimating public health and well-being in the whole population of the Netherlands. We compare the accuracy and performance of these models using out-of-sample predictions with five-fold Cross Validation (5CV). We do this for three data sets of different sample sizes and outcome types. Compared to the STAR model, gradient boosted trees are able to improve both the accuracy of the predictions and the total time taken to get these predictions. Even though the models appear quite similar in overall accuracy, the small area predictions at neighborhood level sometimes differ significantly. It may therefore make sense to pursue slightly more accurate models for better predictions into small areas. However, one of the biggest benefits is that XGBoost does not require prior knowledge or model specification. Data preparation and modelling is much easier, since the method automatically handles missing data, non-linear responses, interactions and accounts for spatial correlation structures. In this paper we provide new nationwide estimates of health, housing and well-being indicators at neighborhood level in the Netherlands, see 'Online materials'. We demonstrate that machine learning provides a good alternative to complex statistical regression modelling for small area estimation in terms of accuracy, robustness, speed and data preparation. These results can be used to make appropriate policy decisions at a local l