“The pandemic only gave visibility to what is invisible”: a qualitative analysis of structural violence during COVID-19 and impacts on gender-based violence in Brazil

• Published in: BMC public health 2023-09, Vol.23 (1), p.1-1854, Article 1854
• Main Authors: Vahedi, Luissa, McNelly, Samantha, Lukow, Nina, Fonseca, Anna Carolina, Erskine, Dorcas, Poulton, Catherine, Stark, Lindsay, Seff, Ilana
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Aggression; Black people; Black women; Brazil; Community; COVID-19; Data reduction; Disease transmission; Displaced persons; Domestic violence; Economic aspects; Epidemics; Family violence; Favela; Food insecurity; Food security; Gender; Gender-based violence; International organizations; Mental health; Mortality; Mortality rates; Murders & murder attempts; Needs; Non-binary gender; Pandemics; Policies; Prevention; Psychological aspects; Qualitative analysis; Qualitative research; Responses; Sanitation; Social aspects; Social mobility; Social response; Social structure; Statistics; Structural violence; Transgender persons; Violence; Violence against children; Brazil; Violence against women
• ISSN: 1471-2458; 1471-2458
• DOI: 10.1186/s12889-023-16675-8

Background The COVID-19 pandemic produced alarming rates of disease and mortality globally, yet few nations were as severely impacted as Brazil. The pandemic also exposed and exacerbated persistent forms of structural violence across Brazil, which complicated gender-based violence (GBV) prevention and response efforts. While structural violence is not new, the systemic pressure and uncertainty introduced by COVID-19 intensified the detrimental impact of structural violence on the lives of Brazilians impacted by GBV. This work qualitatively investigated how the COVID-19 pandemic amplified structural violence and GBV in Brazil. Methods We analyzed key informant interviews (KII) conducted with 12 service providers working in sectors related GBV prevention and response in Roraima, Boa Vista, and Rio de Janeiro. Interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed, and translated from Portuguese or Spanish into English, before applying deductive and inductive coding approaches through a collaborative data reduction process. The theoretical lens of structural violence outlined by Farmer and Rylko-Bauer guided the thematic development. Results Analyses identified three themes. First, structural violence manifests as policies of inaction and erasure, which reduce the opportunity for upward social mobility among GBV survivors including Black women, trans persons, and people who live in the favelas. Policies of inaction and erasure fail to acknowledge/adequately respond to the significant health and safety needs of these communities. Second, structural violence is a fundamental cause of violence against women and children. Finally, service providers described community driven responses that address the dire survival needs (i.e., food insecurity) imposed by COVID-19, within a context of structural violence. These community driven responses were innovative, agile, and based on dire needs expressed to, and observed by, the service providers interviewed. Conclusion This analysis highlights how the COVID-19 pandemic exacerbated existing forms of structural violence prevalent throughout Brazil. Findings stress the urgency with which the Brazilian government and international organization must act to support community driven programs that strive to address the most basic human needs. Keywords: Structural violence, Gender-based violence, Violence against children; Brazil, COVID-19, Food insecurity, Favela