A narrative review of the active ingredients in psychotherapy delivered by conversational agents

• Published in: Computers in human behavior reports 2024-05, Vol.14, p.100401, Article 100401
• Main Authors: Herbener, Arthur Bran, Klincewicz, Michał, Damholdt, Malene Flensborg
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Active ingredient; Artificial intelligence; Chatbot; Conversational agent; Mental health; Psychotherapy
• ISSN: 2451-9588; 2451-9588
• DOI: 10.1016/j.chbr.2024.100401

The present narrative review seeks to unravel where we are now, and where we need to go to delineate the active ingredients in psychotherapy delivered by conversational agents (e.g., chatbots). While psychotherapy delivered by conversational agents has shown promising effectiveness for depression, anxiety, and psychological distress across several randomized controlled trials, little emphasis has been placed on the therapeutic processes in these interventions. The theoretical framework of this narrative review is grounded in prominent perspectives on the active ingredients in psychotherapy. Based on search terms derived from various theoretical perspectives, we conducted a systematic literature search of four scientific databases and identified 17 studies. Across the selected studies, three themes emerged: relationship variables, emotional venting, and cognitive factors. While methodological issues compromise the epistemic value of this evidence base, core questions also remain to be answered. Such questions include, but are not limited to, whether humans can form affectionate bonds to inanimate beings and whether these kind of mental health treatments should be understood as psychotherapy or something else. Researchers should therefore be cautious when applying theories of psychotherapy in the realm of conversational agents. We conclude the paper by introducing recommendations for future research, which we hope will help instigate methodologically sound studies in this field.