A Lost Opportunity? Collective Demands and Migrant Farmworkers in Costa Rica during the Pandemic

• Published in: Studies in social justice 2023-01, Vol.17 (1), p.48-67
• Main Authors: Voorend, Koen, Alvarado Abarca, Daniel, Sáenz Leandro, Ronald
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: collective action; Costa Rica; Covid-19; farmworkers; migrants; Nicaragua
• ISSN: 1911-4788; 1911-4788
• DOI: 10.26522/ssj.v17i1.4034

The COVID-19 pandemic induced an overexposure of migrant farmworkers’ poor working and living conditions in Costa Rica’s northern border area and underscored the country’s dependence on migrant labor. This created a unique opportunity to position pro-migrant concerns and demand actions from the state. In this article, we assess if and to what extent the actions of the Costa Rican state were influenced by migrant demands, or whether other priorities guided policy. Based on a novel database on protest and collective action (Protestas-IIS) that is fed with national and local newspaper articles, we analyze the demands made by migrants, the private sector and NIMBY movements, and state responses. Our findings suggest that the latter prioritized market concerns and antiimmigrant interests, thereby underscoring lessons from the literature that migrants are among the politically most disenfranchised in society. Their demands were only partially responded to by the state, and only concerning issues that aligned directly with public concerns, in this case related to health.