Political culture and the resource curse: public sector corruption across the United States

• Published in: Social responsibility journal 2024-11, Vol.20 (10), p.2084-2099
• Main Author: Mentzer, Marc S.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Corruption; Corruption in government; Cultural values; Culture; Data; Developed countries; Economic development; Economic research; Extraction; Government employees; Jurisdiction; Morality; Natural resources; Political culture; Politics; Public officials; Public sector; Regression analysis; Rule of law; Scandals; States; Variables
• ISSN: 1747-1117; 1747-1117; 1758-857X
• DOI: 10.1108/SRJ-09-2023-0508

Purpose This study aims to examine the connection between political culture and public sector corruption, using the typology of Daniel Elazar, whose model traces the types of political cultures to their origins in various regions of England. Similarly, the “resource curse” concept, generally treated as a national-level phenomenon, is examined to assess how it might vary among jurisdictions within a country. Design/methodology/approach Regression analysis was applied to data from the 50 states of the US. Public sector corruption in each state was operationalized as the number of convictions by the Public Integrity Section of the US Department of Justice in relation to the number of public sector employees in that state. Findings Among the 50 states of the US, support was found for the association between political culture and public sector corruption. On the other hand, whether a state’s economy was dominated by natural resource extraction was not related to public sector corruption. This latter finding suggests the “resource curse” phenomenon does not cause corruption to be worse in states with resource-dependent economies. Research limitations/implications Although it is appropriate to apply regression analysis to a data set of the 50 US states, the small size of the data set limited the number of predictor variables that could be examined. Alternative research approaches are discussed, and it is conceivable that another analytical technique might have revealed other predictors that affect the occurrence of corruption. Originality/value While numerous studies have examined the impact of political culture and resource orientation on corruption at the national level, the current study examines how these variables affect corruption at the level of subnational jurisdictions within a major developed country, the United States.