Understanding sexual violence in sex working populations-Law, legal consciousness and legal practice in four countries

• Published in: PloS one 2023-11, Vol.18 (11), p.e0283067
• Main Authors: Scoular, Jane, Sanders, Teela, Balderston, Susie, Abel, Gillian, Brents, Barbara, Ellison, Graham, Marriott, Nigel
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Analysis; Crimes against; Health aspects; Information management; Labor supply; Laws, regulations and rules; Medical ethics; Prostitutes; Public prosecutors; Safety and security measures; Social aspects; Workplace violence
• ISSN: 1932-6203; 1932-6203
• DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0283067

Globally, the most important human rights and public health issue that sex workers face is their experience of high levels of violence (Kinnell, 2006, Kinnell, 2008, Alexander, 1999). Deering's systematic review estimated levels of sexual violence in sex working populations as being between 14% and 54% (Deering et al, 2014). This international, robust mixed methods study will explore the frequency of sexual violence against sex workers, barriers in criminal justice and the legal consciousness of sex workers regarding their rights and consent. The hypothesis to be tested is that the safety of sex workers from sexual violence is mediated by the differing legal contexts of sex work environments. We will compare experiences across research sites in the context of legalisation (Nevada USA), client criminalisation (Northern Ireland), decriminalisation (New Zealand) and partial criminalisation (England, Scotland and Wales) [henceforth ESW]. An international survey (n = 1,000) will be translated into several languages, to disaggregate experiences by demographic categories (gender, ethnicity, sexual orientation) and sex work sector (including online, street-based and brothels). Interviews (n = 100) with sex workers, police, prosecutors and service providers will be thematically analysed to explore legal consciousness, why the patterns occur and contextualise the statistical findings. These data will be supplemented with comparative legislative, policy and case analysis. Research study data will be used to compare the social factors and legal norms shaping sex workers experiences of sexual violence, justice and support interventions. Recommendations for a 'best practice' review of legal improvements and support interventions will be produced following completion of the study.