The road to virtual control groups and the importance of proper body-weight selection

• Published in: ALTEX, alternatives to animal experimentation alternatives to animal experimentation, 2024-01, Vol.41 (4), p.660
• Main Authors: Gurjanov, Alexander, Vaas, Lea A.I, Steger-Hartmann, Thomas
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Body weight
• ISSN: 1868-596X; 1868-596X
• DOI: 10.14573/altex.2403141

Virtual control groups (VCGs) created from historical control data (HCD) can reduce the number of concurrent control group animals needed in regulatory toxicity studies by up to 25%. This study investigates the performance of VCGs on statistical outcomes of body weight development between treatment and control groups in legacy studies. The objective is to reproduce the statistical outcomes of 28-day sub-chronic studies (legacy studies) after replacing the concurrent control group with virtual ones. In rodent toxicity studies initial body weight is used as surrogate for the age of animals. For the assessment of VCG-sampling methods, three different approaches were explored: (i) sampling VCGs from the entire HCD, ignoring initial body weight information of the legacy study, (ii) sampling from HCD by matching the legacy study's initial body weights, and (iii) sampling from HCD with assigned statistical weights derived from legacy study initial body weight information. The ability to reproduce statistical outcomes using virtual controls was determined by the congruence between the legacy study and the HCD weight distribution: regardless of the chosen approach, the ability to reproduce statistical outcomes was high for VCGs when the legacy study's initial body weight distribution was similar to the HCD's. When the initial body weight range of the legacy study was at the extreme ends of the HCD's distribution, the weighted sampling approach was superior. This article demonstrates the importance of proper HCD matching by the legacy study's initial body weight and discusses conditions to accurately reproduce body weight development. Plain language summary Animal control data from past studies performed in a standardized manner can be used to create virtual control groups (VCGs) to use in new studies instead of control animals. This approach can reduce the number of study animals needed by up to 25%. This study assessed the performance of VCGs selected by body weight in rat studies. The objective was to reproduce the original study results as closely as possible after replacing the original control group values with VCGs from a pool of historical control values. Several methods for selecting control animal data to create VCGs were compared. Among these, assigning statistical weights to the sampling pool yielded the best performance. Ideally, the body weight distributions on day 1 of the study should be similar between the VCG and the original study animals. This ar