Cooperative Effect of Monopodal Silica-Supported Niobium Complex Pairs Enhancing Catalytic Cyclic Carbonate Production

• Published in: Journal of the American Chemical Society 2015-06, Vol.137 (24), p.7728-7739
• Main Authors: D’Elia, Valerio, Dong, Hailin, Rossini, Aaron J, Widdifield, Cory M, Vummaleti, Sai V. C, Minenkov, Yury, Poater, Albert, Abou-Hamad, Edy, Pelletier, Jérémie D. A, Cavallo, Luigi, Emsley, Lyndon, Basset, Jean-Marie
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Analytical chemistry; Chemical Sciences
• ISSN: 0002-7863; 1520-5126
• DOI: 10.1021/jacs.5b02872

Recent discoveries highlighted the activity and the intriguing mechanistic features of NbCl5 as a molecular catalyst for the cycloaddition of CO2 and epoxides under ambient conditions. This has inspired the preparation of novel silica-supported Nb species by reacting a molecular niobium precursor, [NbCl5·OEt2], with silica dehydroxylated at 700 °C (SiO2‑700) or at 200 °C (SiO2‑200) to generate diverse surface complexes. The product of the reaction between SiO2‑700 and [NbCl5·OEt2] was identified as a monopodal supported surface species, [SiONbCl4·OEt2] (1a). The reactions of SiO2‑200 with the niobium precursor, according to two different protocols, generated surface complexes 2a and 3a, presenting significant, but different, populations of the monopodal surface complex along with bipodal [(SiO)2NbCl3·OEt2]. 93Nb solid-state NMR spectra of 1a–3a and 31P solid-state NMR on their PMe3 derivatives 1b–3b led to the unambiguous assignment of 1a as a single-site monopodal Nb species, while 2a and 3a were found to present two distinct surface-supported components, with 2a being mostly monopodal [SiONbCl4·OEt2] and 3a being mostly bipodal [(SiO)2NbCl3·OEt2]. A double-quantum/single-quantum 31P NMR correlation experiment carried out on 2b supported the existence of vicinal Nb centers on the silica surface for this species. 1a–3a were active heterogeneous catalysts for the synthesis of propylene carbonate from CO2 and propylene oxide under mild catalytic conditions; the performance of 2a was found to significantly surpass that of 1a and 3a. With the support of a systematic DFT study carried out on model silica surfaces, the observed differences in catalytic efficiency were correlated with an unprecedented cooperative effect between two neighboring Nb centers on the surface of 2a. This is in an excellent agreement with our previous discoveries regarding the mechanism of NbCl5-catalyzed cycloaddition in the homogeneous phase.