Semiologic subgroups of insulo‐opercular seizures based on connectional architecture atlas

• Published in: Epilepsia (Copenhagen) 2020-05, Vol.61 (5), p.984-994
• Main Authors: Wang, Haixiang, McGonigal, Aileen, Zhang, Kai, Guo, Qiang, Zhang, Bingqing, Wang, Xiu, Wang, Xiao, Lin, Jiuluan, Song, Xiancheng, Feng, Qian, Wang, Siyu, Wang, Mengyang, Shao, Xiaoqiu, Liu, Xiaoyan, Wang, Liang, Zhou, Wenjing
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Brain architecture; Brainnetome Atlas; cluster analysis; Computer Science; Convulsions & seizures; Cortex (insular); Differential diagnosis; Epilepsy; insular seizure; Life Sciences; Limbic system; Localization; Medical Imaging; Neural networks; Operculum; Seizures; semiology; Semiotics; Sensorimotor system; Somatosensory cortex; stereoelectroencephalography; Temporal cortex
• ISSN: 0013-9580; 1528-1167
• DOI: 10.1111/epi.16501

Objective Insulo‐opercular seizures are characterized by diverse semiology, related to the insula's multiple functional roles and extensive connectivity. We aimed to identify semiologic subgroups and correlate these with insulo‐opercular subregions based on connectional architecture. Methods We retrospectively collected a large series of 37 patients with insulo‐opercular seizures explored by stereoelectroencephalography (SEEG) from three epilepsy centers. A new human brain atlas (Brainnetome Atlas, BNA) based on both anatomic and functional connections was employed to segment insulo‐opercular cortex. Semiology and SEEG changes were carefully reviewed and quantified. Principal component analysis and cluster analysis were used to correlate semiologic characteristics with insulo‐opercular subregions. Results Four main semiologic subgroups were identified, organized along an anteroventral to posterodorsal axis based on BNA. Group 1 was characterized by epigastric sensation and/or integrated gestural motor behaviors with or without feelings of fear or rage, involving the anteroventral insular regions and mesial temporal lobes. Group 2 was characterized by auditory sensations and symmetric proximal/axial tonic signs involving the posteroventral temporal operculum. The characteristics of group 3 were orofacial and laryngeal signs, involving the intermediate insulo‐opercular regions. The features of group 4 were somatosensory signs followed by nonintegrated gestural motor behaviors and/or asymmetric tonic signs involving the posterodorsal insulo‐opercular regions with propagation to the mesial frontal lobes. Thus anteroventral seizure organizations predominantly showed limbic system semiology, whereas more posterodorsal regions were associated with semiology involving mainly the sensorimotor system. Subjective symptoms proved to be particularly discriminating factors. Significance Insulo‐opercular seizures can be categorized in terms of clinical semiology and correlate with connectional architecture subregions along an anteroventral‐posterodorsal axis in line with the cytoarchitectonic gradient rather than the gyral anatomy of the insula cortex. This provides new insights into facilitating differential diagnosis and presurgical localization but also highlights the importance of considering connectional architecture in determining neural correlates of complex semiologic patterns.