Three-dimensional muscle loss assessment: a novel computed tomography–based quantitative method to evaluate rotator cuff muscle fatty infiltration

• Published in: Journal of shoulder and elbow surgery 2022-01, Vol.31 (1), p.165-174
• Main Authors: Werthel, Jean-David, Boux de Casson, François, Walch, Gilles, Gaudin, Pascal, Moroder, Philipp, Sanchez-Sotelo, Joaquin, Chaoui, Jean, Burdin, Valérie
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: 3D CT scan; 3D Goutallier; Adipose Tissue - diagnostic imaging; Atrophy; Bioengineering; Goutallier; Humans; Life Sciences; Magnetic Resonance Imaging; Muscle volume; Reproducibility of Results; Rotator Cuff - diagnostic imaging; Rotator Cuff Injuries - diagnostic imaging; Shoulder Joint; Tomography, X-Ray Computed; Volumetric analysis
• ISSN: 1058-2746; 1532-6500
• DOI: 10.1016/j.jse.2021.07.029

Rotator cuff fatty infiltration (FI) is one of the most important parameters to predict the outcome of certain shoulder conditions. The primary objective of this study was to define a new computed tomography (CT)–based quantitative 3-dimensional (3D) measure of muscle loss (3DML) based on the rationale of the 2-dimensional (2D) qualitative Goutallier score. The secondary objective of this study was to compare this new measurement method to traditional 2D qualitative assessment of FI according to Goutallier et al and to a 3D quantitative measurement of fatty infiltration (3DFI). 102 CT scans from healthy shoulders (46) and shoulders with cuff tear arthropathy (21), irreparable rotator cuff tears (18), and primary osteoarthritis (17) were analyzed by 3 experienced shoulder surgeons for subjective grading of fatty infiltration according to Goutallier, and their rotator cuff muscles were manually segmented. Quantitative 3D measurements of fatty infiltration (3DFI) were completed. The volume of muscle fibers without intramuscular fat was then calculated for each rotator cuff muscle and normalized to the patient’s scapular volume to account for the effect of body size (NVfibers). 3D muscle mass (3DMM) was calculated by dividing the NVfibers value of a given muscle by the mean expected volume in healthy shoulders. 3D muscle loss (3DML) was defined as 1 – (3DMM). The correlation between Goutallier grading, 3DFI, and 3DML was compared using a Spearman rank correlation. Interobserver reliability for the traditional 2D Goutallier grading was moderate for the infraspinatus (ISP, 0.42) and fair for the supraspinatus (SSP, 0.38), subscapularis (SSC, 0.27) and teres minor (TM, 0.27). 2D Goutallier grading was found to be significantly and highly correlated with 3DFI (SSP, 0.79; ISP, 0.83; SSC, 0.69; TM, 0.45) and 3DML (SSP, 0.87; ISP, 0.85; SSC, 0.69; TM, 0.46) for all 4 rotator cuff muscles (P < .0001). This correlation was significantly higher for 3DML than for the 3DFI for SSP only (P = .01). The mean values of 3DFI and 3DML were 0.9% and 5.3% for Goutallier 0, 2.9% and 25.6% for Goutallier 1, 11.4% and 49.5% for Goutallier 2, 20.7% and 59.7% for Goutallier 3, and 29.3% and 70.2% for Goutallier 4, respectively. The Goutallier score has been helping surgeons by using 2D CT scan slices. However, this grading is associated with suboptimal interobserver agreement. The new measures we propose provide a more consistent assessment that correlates well with Goutallier’s princ