Challenging the ‘artisanal vs. industrial’ dichotomy in French Atlantic fisheries: An organizational typology of multi-vessel fishing firms

• Published in: Marine policy 2021-12, Vol.134, p.104753, Article 104753
• Main Authors: Kinds, Arne, Le Floc’h, Pascal, Speelman, Stijn, Guyader, Olivier
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Artisanal fisheries; Concentration; Firm governance; Fisheries management; Fishing firms; Life Sciences; Multi-vessel ownership; Organizational structure
• ISSN: 0308-597X; 1872-9460
• DOI: 10.1016/j.marpol.2021.104753

We put under scrutiny the ‘artisanal vs. industrial’ dichotomy used by French fisheries management for classifying fishing operations. Recent evolutions in the Atlantic fishing sector urge us to question its applicability. In particular the definition of the so-called ‘artisanal fishing model’ is under pressure (e.g., decline of family-based fishing, multi-vessel companies increasingly common, emergence of new forms of firm governance). Using mixed-method research (interviews, multiple correspondence analysis (MCA) and hierarchical clustering), we propose a new typology for classifying multi-vessel fishing firms, based on six organizational attributes (ownership structure, firm structure, management strategy, firm size, fishing strategy and valorization strategy). We have carried out a three-step analysis. First, the MCA suggests that the diversity of organizational forms can be described to a great extent in terms of the profile of the owner and the firm’s management and valorization strategies. The cluster analysis then separates organizational configurations in five types, based on cluster-specific modalities: access to key information, legal form, vessel maintenance and standardization, growth objectives and management structure. The final description of the types draws from additional interview data as well as variables that were not used in the analysis. The typology captures the diversity of governance configurations currently existing in the sector, while providing some insight into their origins and future trajectories. We conclude that the artisanal model is outdated and insufficient for describing the organizational diversity of modern-day fishing firms, especially those in the 12–18 m and 18–24 m segments. •The ‘artisanal vs. industrial’ dichotomy traditionally used in French fisheries management is no longer adequate.•Multi-vessel fishing firms in France can be classified in 5 types based on organizational attributes.•There is a high diversity in firm governance and organization across fleet segments.•Across segments, governance is evolving towards scale increase, rationalization, product valorization, access to information.