Understanding the Relationship Between Interactive Optimisation and Visual Analytics in the Context of Prostate Brachytherapy

• Published in: IEEE transactions on visualization and computer graphics 2018-01, Vol.24 (1), p.319-329, Article 319
• Main Authors: Liu, Jie, Dwyer, Tim, Marriott, Kim, Millar, Jeremy, Haworth, Annette
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Analytics; Brachytherapy; interactive optimisation; interactive systems and tools; Mathematical model; Mathematical models; Operations research; Optimization; Planning; Problem solving; Prostate; prostate brachytherapy; Radiation therapy; Therapy; Visual analytics; Visual tasks; Workflow
• ISSN: 1077-2626; 1941-0506; 1941-0506
• DOI: 10.1109/TVCG.2017.2744418

The fields of operations research and computer science have long sought to find automatic solver techniques that can find high-quality solutions to difficult real-world optimisation problems. The traditional workflow is to exactly model the problem and then enter this model into a general-purpose "black-box" solver. In practice, however, many problems cannot be solved completely automatically, but require a "human-in-the-loop" to iteratively refine the model and give hints to the solver. In this paper, we explore the parallels between this interactive optimisation workflow and the visual analytics sense-making loop. We assert that interactive optimisation is essentially a visual analytics task and propose a problem-solving loop analogous to the sense-making loop. We explore these ideas through an in-depth analysis of a use-case in prostate brachytherapy, an application where interactive optimisation may be able to provide significant assistance to practitioners in creating prostate cancer treatment plans customised to each patient's tumour characteristics. However, current brachytherapy treatment planning is usually a careful, mostly manual process involving multiple professionals. We developed a prototype interactive optimisation tool for brachytherapy that goes beyond current practice in supporting focal therapy - targeting tumour cells directly rather than simply seeking coverage of the whole prostate gland. We conducted semi-structured interviews, in two stages, with seven radiation oncology professionals in order to establish whether they would prefer to use interactive optimisation for treatment planning and whether such a tool could improve their trust in the novel focal therapy approach and in machine generated solutions to the problem.