The Effect of Broad and Specific Demographic Homogeneity on the Imposter Distributions and False Match Rates in Face Recognition Algorithm Performance

• Main Authors: Howard, John J., Sirotin, Yevgeniy B., Vemury, Arun R.
• Format: Conference Proceeding
• Language: English
• Subjects: Error analysis; Face; Face recognition; Frequency modulation; Skin; Task analysis; Terrorism
• ISSN: 2474-9699
• DOI: 10.1109/BTAS46853.2019.9186002

The growing adoption of biometric identity systems, notably face recognition, has raised questions regarding whether performance is equitable across demographic groups. Prior work on this issue showed that performance of face recognition systems varies with demographic variables. However, biometric systems make two distinct types of matching errors, which lead to different outcomes for users depending on the technology use case. In this research, we develop a framework for classifying biometric performance differentials that separately considers the effect of false positive and false negative outcomes, and show that oft-cited evidence regarding biometric equitability has focused on primarily on false-negatives. We then correlate demographic variables with false-positive outcomes in a diverse population using a commercial face recognition algorithm, and show that false match rate (FMR) at a fixed threshold increases >400-fold for broadly homogeneous groups (individuals of the same age, same gender, and same race) relative to heterogeneous groups. This was driven by systematic shifts in the tails of the imposter distribution impelled primarily by homogeneity in race and gender. For specific demographic groups, we observed the highest false match rate for older males that self-identified as White and the lowest for older males that self-identified as Black or African American. The magnitude of FMR differentials between specific homogeneous groups (