Virtual extensions improve perception-based instrument alignment using optical see-through devices

• Published in: IEEE transactions on visualization and computer graphics 2021-11, Vol.27 (11), p.4332-4341
• Main Authors: Benmahdjoub, Mohamed, Niessen, Wiro J., Wolvius, Eppo B., van Walsum, Theo
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Alignment; Angular velocity; Augmented reality; Data visualization; Estimation; Instrument alignment; Instruments; Navigation system; Surgery; Task analysis; Three-dimensional displays; Trajectory; User study; Virtual reality; Visualization
• ISSN: 1077-2626; 1941-0506
• DOI: 10.1109/TVCG.2021.3106506

Instrument alignment is a common task in various surgical interventions using navigation. The goal of the task is to position and orient an instrument as it has been planned preoperatively. To this end, surgeons rely on patient-specific data visualized on screens alongside preplanned trajectories. The purpose of this manuscript is to investigate the effect of instrument visualization/non visualization on alignment tasks, and to compare it with virtual extensions approach which augments the realistic representation of the instrument with simple 3D objects. 18 volunteers performed six alignment tasks under each of the following conditions: no visualization on the instrument; realistic visualization of the instrument; realistic visualization extended with virtual elements (Virtual extensions). The first condition represents an egocentric-based alignment while the two other conditions additionally make use of exocentric depth estimation to perform the alignment. The device used was a see-through device (Microsoft HoloLens 2). The positions of the head and the instrument were acquired during the experiment. Additionally, the users were asked to fill NASA-TLX and SUS forms for each condition. The results show that instrument visualization is essential for a good alignment using see-through devices. Moreover, virtual extensions helped achieve the best performance compared to the other conditions with medians of 2 mm and 2° positional and angular error respectively. Furthermore, the virtual extensions decreased the average head velocity while similarly reducing the frustration levels. Therefore, making use of virtual extensions could facilitate alignment tasks in augmented and virtual reality (AR/VR) environments, specifically in AR navigated surgical procedures when using optical see-through devices.