From indicators to indicating interdisciplinarity: A participatory mapping methodology for research communities in-the-making

• Published in: Quantitative science studies 2020-09, Vol.1 (3), p.1041-1055
• Main Authors: Marres, Noortje, de Rijcke, Sarah
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: digital cartography; interdisciplinarity; inventive methods; participatory methods; Science and Technology Indicators; Science and Technology Studies
• ISSN: 2641-3337; 2641-3337
• DOI: 10.1162/qss_a_00062

This article discusses a project under development called “Inventing Indicators of Interdisciplinarity,” as an example of work in methodology development that combines quantitative methods with interpretative approaches in social and cultural research. Key to our project is the idea that Science and Technology Indicators not only have representative value, enabling empirical insight into fields of research and innovation but simultaneously have organizing capacity, as their deployment enables the curation of communities of interpretation. We begin with a discussion of concepts and methods for the analysis of interdisciplinarity in Science and Technology Studies (STS) and scientometrics, stressing that both fields recognize that interdisciplinarity is contested. To make possible a constructive exploration of interdisciplinarity as a contested—and transformative—phenomenon, we sketch out a methodological framework for the development and deployment of “engaging indicators.” We characterize this methodology of as participatory, abductive, interactive, and informed by design, and emphasize that the method is inherently combinatory, as it brings together approaches from scientometrics, STS, and humanities research. In a final section, we test the potential of our approach in a pilot study of interdisciplinarity in AI, and offer reflections on digital mapping as a pathway towards interdisciplinarity.