Reliability of Goldberg Scoring System in the Radiographic Evaluation of Bony Union after Bone Grafting

• Published in: Clinics in orthopedic surgery 2021, 13(4), , pp.549-557
• Main Authors: Choi, Young, Yang, Young Hoon, Kwon, Young-Ho
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Animals; Bone Transplantation; Hand; Humans; Male; Mice; Mice, Inbred C57BL; Observer Variation; Original; Orthopedics; Reproducibility of Results; Swine; 정형외과학
• ISSN: 2005-291X; 2005-4408
• DOI: 10.4055/cios19152

Evaluation of bony union after bone grafting is very important in orthopedic surgery. The aim of this study was to verify inter- and intraobserver reliability of the Goldberg scoring system for radiographic evaluation of bony union after bone grafting in various situations of animal models. Twenty-seven male C57/BL6 mice, which lack the ability to synthesize galactose-alpha-1,3-galactose (GalT KO mice), and 9 C57/BL6 mice carrying a wild-type gene were used as animal models. We divided the mice into four groups. In group 1, syngenic bone grafting and intramedullary fixation were performed (9 wild type C57BL/6 mice). In group 2, allogenic bone grafting was performed (9 GalT KO mice). In group 3, an alpha-galactosidase-treated porcine xenograft was transplanted into the femur to reduce the antigenicity (9 GalT KO mice). In group 4, a non-treated porcine xenobone grafting was performed (9 GalT KO mice). The level of radiographic bony union (Goldberg method) was assessed by three orthopedic surgeons. Intra- and interobserver reliability for radiographic evaluation was assessed. In the Goldberg scoring system, most of the radiographic measurements showed substantial to almost perfect intraobserver reliability. The total score showed substantial intraobserver reliability. The kappa coefficient (κ) of the first examiner was 0.603, the κ of the second examiner was 0.790, and the κ of the third examiner was 0.758. The scoring system showed substantial interobserver reliability. The κ of the first session was 0.641 and the κ of the second session was 0.649. The Goldberg scoring system is a reliable tool for radiographic evaluation of bony union after bone grafting.