Impact of Smoke Exposure on Digital Instrumentation and Control

• Published in: Nuclear technology 2003-08, Vol.143 (2), p.152-160
• Main Authors: Tanaka, Tina J., Nowlen, Steven P., Korsah, Kofi, Wood, Richard T., Antonescu, Christina E.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Applied sciences; COATINGS; CONTROL; CONTROL SYSTEMS; DIGITAL CIRCUITS; DIGITAL SYSTEMS; ELECTRIC POTENTIAL; Energy; Energy. Thermal use of fuels; Exact sciences and technology; FAILURES; Fission nuclear power plants; HEAT; HUMIDITY; Installations for energy generation and conversion: thermal and electrical energy; LEAKAGE CURRENT; MAGNETIC DISKS; METALS; NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS; POLYURETHANES; RECOMMENDATIONS; SMOKES; SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS
• ISSN: 0029-5450; 1943-7471
• DOI: 10.13182/NT03-A3405

Smoke can cause interruptions and upsets in active electronics. Because nuclear power plants are replacing analog with digital instrumentation and control systems, qualification guidelines for new systems are being reviewed for severe environments such as smoke and electromagnetic interference. Active digital systems, individual components, and active circuits have been exposed to smoke in a program sponsored by the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission. The circuits and systems were all monitored during the smoke exposure, indicating any immediate effects of the smoke. The results of previous smoke exposure studies have been reported in various publications. The major immediate effect of smoke has been to increase leakage currents and to cause momentary upsets and failures in digital systems. This paper presents new results from conformal coatings, memory chips, and hard drive tests. The best conformal coatings were found to be polyurethane, parylene, and acrylic (when applied by dipping). Conformal coatings can reduce smoke-induced leakage currents and protect against metal loss through corrosion. However conformal coatings are typically flammable, so they do increase material flammability. Some of the low-voltage biased memory chips failed during a combination of high smoke and high humidity. Typically, smoke along with heat and humidity is expected during fire, rather than smoke alone. Thus, due to high sensitivity of digital circuits to heat and humidity, it is hypothesized that the impact of smoke may be secondary. Low-voltage (3.3-V) static random-access memory (SRAMs) were found to be the most vulnerable to smoke. Higher bias voltages decrease the likelihood of failure. Erasable programmable read-only memory (EPROMs) and nonvolatile SRAMs were very smoke tolerant. Failures of the SRAMs occurred when two conditions were present: high density of smoke and high humidity. As the high humidity was present for only part of the test, the failures were intermittent. All of the chips that failed during the test recovered after enough venting. Hard disks were tested in severe environments but did not fail during the 2 h of monitoring. While the results of the tests documented in this report confirm that digital circuits can indeed be vulnerable to smoke, there is currently no practical, repeatable testing methodology, so it is not feasible to assess smoke susceptibility as part of environmental qualification. As a result, the most reasonable approach to minimiz