Mosquitoes and bednets: testing the spatial positioning of insecticide on nets and the rationale behind combination insecticide treatments

• Published in: Annals of tropical medicine and parasitology 2008-12, Vol.102 (8), p.717-727
• Main Authors: Oxborough, R. M., Mosha, F. W., Matowo, J., Mndeme, R., Feston, E., Hemingway, J., Rowland, M.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Animals; Anopheles - drug effects; Anopheles - physiology; Anopheles gambiae; Bedding and Linens; Behavior, Animal; Biological and medical sciences; Biological Assay; Female; General aspects; Humans; Insecticide Resistance; Insecticides; Logistic Models; Malaria - prevention & control; Medical sciences; Mosquito Control - methods; Nitriles; Pyrethrins
• ISSN: 0003-4983; 1364-8594
• DOI: 10.1179/136485908X337553

The recent development of pyrethroid resistance of operational significance in Anopheles gambiae s.l. is a major threat to the control of malaria in West Africa. The so-called '2-in-1' bednet, in which the top of the net is treated with a non-pyrethroid insecticide and the sides with pyrethroid, has been proposed as a way of maintaining efficacy in the wake of such resistance. A host-seeking female Anopheles mosquito must contact both the top and sides of a '2-in-1' net, however, for such nets to be useful in resistance management. In the present study, the interaction between mosquitoes and insecticide-treated bednets (ITN) was explored by restricting the insecticide to particular surfaces of the nets (top only or sides only) and then testing these nets, untreated nets and nets treated on all their surfaces in experimental huts, under simulated field conditions. Over the 6-week trial, there was no significant difference in An. arabiensis mortality between nets treated with pyrethroid on the top only (39.2%), sides only (39.6%) and all surfaces (39.7%), thus indicating that a female An. arabiensis usually contacts both the top and sides of a bednet during its host-seeking behaviour. The data on blood-feeding indicated, however, that the insecticide used on the sides of the net may be more important in preventing mosquito biting than that on the top. These results support the rationale behind the '2-in-1' nets. Such nets may have advantages over the use of nets treated on all surfaces with a mixture of insecticides that includes a non-pyrethroid component. With the '2-in-1', the more toxic component can be deployed on the top of the net, away from human contact, while the more repellent pyrethroid can be restricted to the sides, to prevent blood-feeding. With the scaling-up of ITN coverage and the need to preserve pyrethroid efficacy, more consideration should be given to switching from pyrethroid-only nets to 'combination' nets that have been treated with a pyrethroid and another insecticide. Since the mosquitoes that act as malarial vectors may contact all surfaces of a bednet during their host-seeking, spatial heterogeneity in insecticide levels over the surface of a net may not reduce that net's overall efficacy. Nets with a rather uneven distribution of insecticide (such as those that might be produced using home-treatment insecticide kits) may therefore be no less effective, prior to washing, than nets with a more even distribution of insecticide (suc