The empirical analysis of cigarette tax avoidance and illicit trade in Vietnam, 1998-2010

• Published in: PloS one 2014-01, Vol.9 (1), p.e87272-e87272
• Main Authors: Nguyen, Minh Thac, Denniston, Ryan, Nguyen, Hien Thi Thu, Hoang, Tuan Anh, Ross, Hana, So, Anthony D
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Bans; Cigarette industry; Cigarettes; Commerce - economics; Consumer Price Index; Consumers; Consumption; Costs; Crime - economics; Crime - statistics & numerical data; Economics; Empirical analysis; Empirical Research; Estimates; Excise taxes; Global health; Health care; Health care costs; Humans; International economic relations; International trade; Joint ventures; Licenses; Lung diseases; Market surveys; Measurement methods; Medicine; Polls & surveys; Public health; Public policy; R&D; Research & development; Science Policy; Smoking; Smoking - epidemiology; Smuggling; Social and Behavioral Sciences; Surveys; Tax evasion; Tax increases; Taxation; Taxes; Tobacco; Tobacco industry; Tobacco Industry - economics; Tobacco Products - economics; Trade; Trends; Tuberculosis; Upper bounds; Vietnam
• ISSN: 1932-6203; 1932-6203
• DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0087272

Illicit trade carries the potential to magnify existing tobacco-related health care costs through increased availability of untaxed and inexpensive cigarettes. What is known with respect to the magnitude of illicit trade for Vietnam is produced primarily by the industry, and methodologies are typically opaque. Independent assessment of the illicit cigarette trade in Vietnam is vital to tobacco control policy. This paper measures the magnitude of illicit cigarette trade for Vietnam between 1998 and 2010 using two methods, discrepancies between legitimate domestic cigarette sales and domestic tobacco consumption estimated from surveys, and trade discrepancies as recorded by Vietnam and trade partners. The results indicate that Vietnam likely experienced net smuggling in during the period studied. With the inclusion of adjustments for survey respondent under-reporting, inward illicit trade likely occurred in three of the four years for which surveys were available. Discrepancies in trade records indicate that the value of smuggled cigarettes into Vietnam ranges from $100 million to $300 million between 2000 and 2010 and that these cigarettes primarily originate in Singapore, Hong Kong, Macao, Malaysia, and Australia. Notable differences in trends over time exist between the two methods, but by comparison, the industry estimates consistently place the magnitude of illicit trade at the upper bounds of what this study shows. The unavailability of annual, survey-based estimates of consumption may obscure the true, annual trend over time. Second, as surveys changed over time, estimates relying on them may be inconsistent with one another. Finally, these two methods measure different components of illicit trade, specifically consumption of illicit cigarettes regardless of origin and smuggling of cigarettes into a particular market. However, absent a gold standard, comparisons of different approaches to illicit trade measurement serve efforts to refine and improve measurement approaches and estimates.