Effects of Steroids on Quality of Recovery and Adverse Events after General Anesthesia: Meta-Analysis and Trial Sequential Analysis of Randomized Clinical Trials

• Published in: PloS one 2016-09, Vol.11 (9), p.e0162961-e0162961
• Main Authors: Mihara, Takahiro, Ishii, Tomoko, Ka, Koui, Goto, Takahisa
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Anesthesia; Anesthesia, General - adverse effects; Anesthesiology; Bias; Clinical trials; Complications and side effects; Confidence intervals; Critical care; Dexamethasone; Dexamethasone - administration & dosage; Drug dosages; Handbooks; Humans; Medical research; Medicine; Medicine and Health Sciences; Meta-analysis; Methods; Nausea; Pain; Patients; Physical Sciences; Product development; Quality; Quality assessment; Quality of life; Randomization; Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic; Recovery; Research and Analysis Methods; Sensitivity analysis; Sequential analysis; Statistical analysis; Steroid hormones; Steroids; Studies; Surgery; Systematic review; University graduates; Upgrading
• ISSN: 1932-6203; 1932-6203
• DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0162961

Quality of recovery (QoR) after surgery is a relevant outcome. The early postoperative quality of recovery of a patient can be determined using the QoR-40 questionnaire. The aim of this meta-analysis and Trial Sequential Analysis was to determine if perioperative administration of glucocorticosteroids improved patients' quality of recovery after general anesthesia and if adverse events occurred. We searched six databases, including trial registration sites. Randomized clinical trials reporting the efficacy of glucocorticosteroids on quality of recovery evaluated using the QoR-40 after general anesthesia were eligible. The QoR-40 data were combined as the mean difference with confidence intervals using a random-effects model. The I2 statistic was used to assess heterogeneity. The quality of the trials was evaluated using the Cochrane methodology. Moreover, Trial Sequential Analysis was carried out to prevent the inflation of type 1 errors caused by multiple testing and sparse data. We also assessed adverse events. Three randomized clinical trials (totaling 301 patients) were analyzed. The results from one published and four unpublished randomized clinical trials were unavailable. Dexamethasone was investigated in all three trials, and the results suggested that it significantly improved QoR-40 at postoperative day one scores compared with placebo (mean difference [95% confidence interval]: 14.2 points [10.4 to 18.1]; P < 0.001; I2 = 0%). We could not conduct sensitivity analysis because of the absence of trials with low risk of bias. The Trial Sequential Analysis-adjusted confidence interval was -1.6 to 30.0, indicating that further trials are required. The reporting of adverse events was insufficient. These findings indicate that perioperative dexamethasone administration may improve short-term (i.e., one day) quality of recovery after general anesthesia and surgery. We need more randomized clinical trials with low risk of bias assessing the effects of glucocorticosteroids on quality of life, other outcomes, and adverse events. Updated systematic reviews should then be conducted. University Hospital Medical Information Network Clinical Trials Registry: UMIN000015678.