Patterns of brown bear damages on apiaries and management recommendations in the Cantabrian Mountains, Spain

• Published in: PloS one 2018-11, Vol.13 (11), p.e0206733-e0206733
• Main Authors: Naves, Javier, Ordiz, Andrés, Fernández-Gil, Alberto, Penteriani, Vincenzo, Delgado, María Del Mar, López-Bao, José Vicente, Revilla, Eloy, Delibes, Miguel
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Analysis; Animal behavior; Animal populations; Animals; Bears; Beehives; Beekeeping; Behavior, Animal; Biodiversity; Biology and Life Sciences; Brown bears; Carnivores; Conflict; Conservation; Conservation biology; Conservation of Natural Resources - methods; Damage prevention; Ecology and Environmental Sciences; Engineering and Technology; Environment; Environmental factors; Environmental protection; Food; Food availability; Food resources; Food security; Human settlements; Infrastructure (Economics); Land settlement; Landscape preservation; Livestock; Mountains; People and Places; Physical Sciences; Physiological aspects; Planning; Plants; Prevention; Probability; Spain; Spatio-Temporal Analysis; Ursidae; Ursus arctos; Vegetation cover; Wildlife conservation
• ISSN: 1932-6203; 1932-6203
• DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0206733

Large carnivores are often persecuted due to conflict with human activities, making their conservation in human-modified landscapes very challenging. Conflict-related scenarios are increasing worldwide, due to the expansion of human activities or to the recovery of carnivore populations. In general, brown bears Ursus arctos avoid humans and their settlements, but they may use some areas close to people or human infrastructures. Bear damages in human-modified landscapes may be related to the availability of food resources of human origin, such as beehives. However, the association of damage events with factors that may predispose bears to cause damages has rarely been investigated. We investigated bear damages to apiaries in the Cantabrian Mountains (Spain), an area with relatively high density of bears. We included spatial, temporal and environmental factors and damage prevention measures in our analyses, as factors that may influence the occurrence and intensity of damages. In 2006-2008, we located 61 apiaries, which included 435 beehives damaged in the study area (346 km2). The probability of an apiary being attacked was positively related to both the intensity of the damage suffered the year before and the distance to the nearest damaged apiary, and negatively related to the number of prevention measures employed as well as the intensity of the damage suffered by the nearest damage apiary. The intensity of damage to apiaries was positively related to the size of the apiary and to vegetation cover in the surroundings, and negatively related to the number of human settlements. Minimizing the occurrence of bear damages to apiaries seems feasible by applying and maintaining proper prevention measures, especially before an attack occurs and selecting appropriate locations for beehives (e.g. away from forest areas). This applies to areas currently occupied by bears, and to neighbouring areas where dispersing individuals may expand their range.