Automated analysis of soft hydrogel microindentation: Impact of various indentation parameters on the measurement of Young's modulus

• Published in: PloS one 2019-08, Vol.14 (8), p.e0220281-e0220281
• Main Authors: Huth, Steven, Sindt, Sandra, Selhuber-Unkel, Christine
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Algorithms; Applied physics; Atomic force microscopes; Atomic force microscopy; Automation; Biocompatibility; Biomechanics; Data analysis; Earth Sciences; Elastic Modulus; Elastic properties; Engineering and Technology; Experiments; Force; Homogeneity; Hydrogels; Information management; Isotropy; Materials science; Materials Testing - methods; Mathematical models; Mechanical properties; Microhardness; Microscopy; Models, Theoretical; Modulus of elasticity; Nanomaterials; Parameters; Physical Sciences; Polyacrylamide; Polymers; Research and Analysis Methods; Sliding friction; Statistical methods; Topography
• ISSN: 1932-6203; 1932-6203
• DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0220281

Measurements of Young's moduli are mostly evaluated using strong assumptions, such as sample homogeneity and isotropy. At the same time, descriptions of measurement parameters often lack detailed specifications. Many of these assumptions are, for soft hydrogels especially, not completely valid and the complexity of hydrogel microindentation demands more sophisticated experimental procedures in order to describe their elastic properties more accurately. We created an algorithm that automates indentation data analysis as a basis for the evaluation of large data sets with consideration of the influence of indentation depth on the measured Young's modulus. The algorithm automatically determines the Young's modulus in indentation regions where it becomes independent of the indentation depth and furthermore minimizes the error from fitting an elastic model to the data. This approach is independent of the chosen elastic fitting model and indentation device. With this, we are able to evaluate large amounts of indentation curves recorded on many different sample positions and can therefore apply statistical methods to overcome deviations due to sample inhomogeneities. To prove the applicability of our algorithm, we carried out a systematic analysis of how the indentation speed, indenter size and sample thickness affect the determination of Young's modulus from atomic force microscope (AFM) indentation curves on polyacrylamide (PAAm) samples. We chose the Hertz model as the elastic fitting model for this proof of principle of our algorithm and found that all of these parameters influence the measured Young's moduli to a certain extent. Hence, it is essential to clearly state the experimental parameters used in microindentation experiments to ensure reproducibility and comparability of data.