Protons in small spaces: Discrete simulations of vesicle acidification

• Published in: PLoS computational biology 2019-12, Vol.15 (12), p.e1007539-e1007539
• Main Authors: Singh, Apeksha, Marcoline, Frank V, Veshaguri, Salome, Kao, Aimee W, Bruchez, Marcel, Mindell, Joseph A, Stamou, Dimitrios, Grabe, Michael
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Acidification; Biology and Life Sciences; Buffers; Chemical reactions; Chemistry; Computational Biology; Computer Simulation; Continuum modeling; Copy number; Differential equations; Fluctuations; Fluorescent Dyes; Fluorescent indicators; Heterogeneity; Hydrogen-Ion Concentration; Ion flux; Ion Transport; Laboratories; Mathematical models; Membrane permeability; Membrane potential; Membrane Potentials; Membranes; Models, Biological; Noise; Ordinary differential equations; Organelles - metabolism; Parameter estimation; Permeability; pH effects; Pharmaceuticals; Physical Sciences; Proteins; Proton Pumps - metabolism; Protons; Pumps; Regulatory sequences; Research and Analysis Methods; Stochastic models; Stochastic Processes; Stochasticity; Vesicles; Work capacity
• ISSN: 1553-7358; 1553-734X; 1553-7358
• DOI: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1007539

The lumenal pH of an organelle is one of its defining characteristics and central to its biological function. Experiments have elucidated many of the key pH regulatory elements and how they vary from compartment-to-compartment, and continuum mathematical models have played an important role in understanding how these elements (proton pumps, counter-ion fluxes, membrane potential, buffering capacity, etc.) work together to achieve specific pH setpoints. While continuum models have proven successful in describing ion regulation at the cellular length scale, it is unknown if they are valid at the subcellular level where volumes are small, ion numbers may fluctuate wildly, and biochemical heterogeneity is large. Here, we create a discrete, stochastic (DS) model of vesicular acidification to answer this question. We used this simplified model to analyze pH measurements of isolated vesicles containing single proton pumps and compared these results to solutions from a continuum, ordinary differential equations (ODE)-based model. Both models predict similar parameter estimates for the mean proton pumping rate, membrane permeability, etc., but, as expected, the ODE model fails to report on the fluctuations in the system. The stochastic model predicts that pH fluctuations decrease during acidification, but noise analysis of single-vesicle data confirms our finding that the experimental noise is dominated by the fluorescent dye, and it reveals no insight into the true noise in the proton fluctuations. Finally, we again use the reduced DS model explore the acidification of large, lysosome-like vesicles to determine how stochastic elements, such as variations in proton-pump copy number and cycling between on and off states, impact the pH setpoint and fluctuations around this setpoint.