Statistical analysis considerations within longitudinal studies of physical qualities in youth athletes: A qualitative systematic methodological review

• Published in: PloS one 2022-07, Vol.17 (7), p.e0270336-e0270336
• Main Authors: Owen, Cameron, Till, Kevin, Darrall-Jones, Josh, Jones, Ben
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Age; Athletes; Biology and Life Sciences; Body measurements; Data collection; Development systems; Evaluation; Growth models; Health aspects; Longitudinal studies; Medicine and Health Sciences; Missing data; Multidimensional methods; Physical Sciences; Physiological aspects; Professional development; R&D; Research & development; Research and Analysis Methods; Research design; Social Sciences; Statistical analysis; Statistical methods; Statistics; Teenagers; Time measurement; Unstructured data; Variance analysis; Workloads; Youth
• ISSN: 1932-6203; 1932-6203
• DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0270336

The evaluation of physical qualities in talent identification and development systems is vital and commonplace in supporting youth athletes towards elite sport. However, the complex and dynamic development of physical qualities in addition to temporal challenges associated with the research design, such as unstructured data collection and missing data, requires appropriate statistical methods to be applied in research to optimise the understanding and knowledge of long-term physical development. To collate and evaluate the application of methodological and statistical methods used in studies investigating the development of physical qualities within youth athletes. Electronic databases were systematically searched form the earliest record to June 2021 and reference lists were hand searched in accordance with the PRISMA guidelines. Studies were included if they tested physical qualities over a minimum of 3 timepoints, were observational in nature and used youth sporting populations. Forty articles met the inclusion criteria. The statistical analysis methods applied were qualitatively assessed against the theoretical underpinnings (i.e. multidimensional development, non-linear change and between and within athlete change) and temporal challenges (i.e. time variant and invariant variables, missing data, treatment of time and repeated measures) encountered with longitudinal physical testing research. Multilevel models were implemented most frequently (50%) and the most appropriately used statistical analysis method when qualitatively compared against the longitudinal challenges. Independent groups ANOVA, MANOVA and X.sup.2 were also used, yet failed to address any of the challenges posed within longitudinal physical testing research. This methodological review identified the statistical methods currently employed within longitudinal physical testing research and addressed the theoretical and temporal challenges faced in longitudinal physical testing research with varying success. The findings can be used to support the selection of statistical methods when evaluating the development of youth athletes through the consideration of the challenges presented.