Home and Office: Some Trends of Modernization among the Kanya-Kubja Brahmans

• Published in: Comparative studies in society and history 1971-04, Vol.13 (2), p.196-216
• Main Author: Khare, R. S.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Deities; Dharma; Economic development; Funerary rituals; Indian culture; Karma; Kinship; Religious rituals; Social change; Traditionalism
• ISSN: 0010-4175; 1475-2999; 1471-633X
• DOI: 10.1017/S0010417500006204

Recently Singer (1966: 497–505), while reviewing a book on economic development and Hinduism, underlined the necessity of recognizing the ‘deficiencies’ of the hypothetico-deductive method in studying social change in India. He alluded to Weber's thesis (ideal-typical relations of the Hindu ‘ethic’ to economic development) and its possible ‘distortions’ under this approach, especially if applied ‘as a basis for quick diagnoses of the ideological and structural factors impeding or facilitating economic development…’ (p. 498), or when applied to a general analysis of the social and cultural ‘transformations’ involved in modernization. He noted two major limitations: first, that under hypothetico-deductive use of ideal types one tries to deduce ‘realistic consequences from basic beliefs, values, motives postulated in isolation from concrete social and cultural contexts’ (p. 501), and second (which is perhaps a related consequence), that when deducing general tendencies, one fails ‘to specify conditions and magnitudes under which the conclusions are valid’ (p. 502). While Singer recognizes that this approach ‘will eventually complement’anthropologists’ narrative, descriptive, and inductive approaches, he stresses that the present need is to accumulate relevant empirical studies of the latter kind, against which we can check the conclusions of hypothetico-deductive theory.