Loading…

Against democratic intergovernmentalism: The case for a theory of constituent power in the global realm

The normative school of global constitutionalism lacks a convincing model of constitutional politics. As far as the democratic legitimacy of constitution making at the supra-state level is addressed at all, scholars usually resort to democratic intergovernmentalism. According to this normative model...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Published in:International journal of constitutional law 2016-07, Vol.14 (3), p.622-638
Main Author: Patberg, Markus
Format: Article
Language:English
Subjects:
Citations: Items that cite this one
Online Access:Get full text
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
Description
Summary:The normative school of global constitutionalism lacks a convincing model of constitutional politics. As far as the democratic legitimacy of constitution making at the supra-state level is addressed at all, scholars usually resort to democratic intergovernmentalism. According to this normative model, processes in which constitutional norms in the global realm are made or amended are democratically legitimate if they are organized as treaty making among the executives of democratic states, followed by parliamentary ratification. In this article, I argue that this model should be rejected because it puts the democratic legal domestication of public authority at risk. Specifically, democratic intergovernmentalism is characterized by five shortcomings: (a) it does not distinguish between norms of contractual and constitutional quality; (b) it undermines the separation of powers; (c) it breaches the division and hierarchization of constituent and constituted powers; (d) it disregards the deliberative dimension of democratic control; and (e) it does neither provide the citizens nor their representatives with a capacity to begin. Ultimately, I suggest that a superior approach should build on the notion of constituent power.
ISSN:1474-2640
1474-2659
DOI:10.1093/icon/mow040