Building Dignity?: Tracing Rights, Discretion, and Negotiation within a Norwegian Labor Activation Program

• Published in: International journal of social quality 2016-12, Vol.6 (2), p.52-70
• Main Authors: Gubrium, Erika, Johnstone, Leah, Lødemel, Ivar
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Analysis; Civil rights; Economic aspects; Human dignity; Labor; Laws, regulations and rules; Methods; Norway; Public assistance; Social aspects
• ISSN: 1757-0344; 1757-0352
• DOI: 10.3167/IJSQ.2016.060205

Within a Norwegian labor activation program for social assistance, we explore how the presence of a work-oriented ethos shapes and changes the balance of rights, discretion, and negotiation available to and marking the interactions between service providers and program participants. We trace connections between changed delivery interactions and heightened shame or enhanced dignity for participants. Two themes emerge, the first related to an imagined institutional trajectory of progress attached to labor activation in which participants were offered “more” and the second to whether participants and caseworkers had a meaningful voice in co-negotiating the terms of activation. Unrealistic optimism and an institutional focus placed on individual participants’ new responsibilities fueled a longer-term negative impact. Descriptions of enhanced rights, new possibilities for negotiation, and reported feelings of shame and frustration depended both on the participant’s distance to the labor market and on the point at which respondents were interviewed.